Key findings
- 4,943Academic Clinical Fellowships funded by NIHR since 2006, with fill rates averaging 98%
- 1,814Clinical Lectureships funded by NIHR; within 5 years of completing their award, 95% of CLs remained research active
- 4,902NMAHPs funded by NIHR since 2009, with numbers increasing substantially in the last 5 years
Introduction
In 2005, the UK Clinical Research Collaboration published a seminal report1 that recognised the challenges facing medical and dental academics and made recommendations for a new clinical academic pathway which fully integrated both clinical and academic training across all stages of career. A follow on report2 set out further recommendations for the careers of nurses, midwives and allied health professions (NMAHPs).
The career pathways that followed were unique; they brought together partner organisations who took joint responsibility for clinical academics helping them navigate the movement between different sectors and allowing them to embed research into clinical practice. The National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR), through its Academy, implemented these new pathways and over two decades refined its approach building on the knowledge and experience gained along the way. This article looks at what we learned and puts forward the key elements that contributed to success and the challenges that remain.
What we wanted to achieve
The landscape back then looked very different. Clinicians mostly undertook research projects unconnected to clinical expertise and for NMAHPs in particular, opportunities to undertake research alongside a clinical career were few and far between. As a funder, NIHR wanted to offer attractive opportunities that would build capacity and capability and ensure research became an integrated part of clinical practice. Pathways had to be flexible with clear entry and exit points and designed to maximise career progression, improve diversity and create future leaders.
Success and Challenges
Close working between partners was established early on and became a key feature that we came to rely upon. Medical and dental posts were awarded to a tripartite partnership which included medical schools, postgraduate deaneries and NHS organisations. The partners identified training leads to take local responsibility for trainees and established schools, many of which embraced a multiprofessional approach to training including NMAHPs and other healthcare professionals. The local support and close interface with NIHR Academy were instrumental in solving issues for individuals quickly, but also in identifying broader challenges that required strategic partners to work together to find solutions. Challenges included the difficulty of balancing clinical and academic commitments, the movement between academic and clinical environments, potential loss of employment benefits, impact on pensions, ensuring pay parity with clinical roles and finding ongoing opportunities for career progression. Funders worked together to ensure their schemes were complementary and set out expectations and obligations for host organisations, trainees and for the funders themselves.3,4
Since 2006, NIHR has funded 4,943 Academic Clinical Fellowships (ACFs), a 3-year predoctoral fellowship combining clinical and academic training that provides early exposure to research and acts as a bridge to securing PhD funding. This has built substantial research capacity and delivered a pipeline of clinical academics using opportunities that previously did not exist. The posts proved popular with fill rates averaging 98%. Undertaking an ACF increased the likelihood of securing an externally funded doctoral training award and onward progression to senior academic posts5. 1592 (40%) ACFs attained 3806 further funding awards and leveraged a total of £1,718,012,697. Within 5 years of completing their award, 86% of Fellows remained research active with over 5200 publications, many of which impacted policy guidance and changes in practice.
The NIHR has also funded 1,814 Clinical Lectureships (CLs), a 4 year postdoctoral award funding both clinical and academic training. The CL is a critical step to independence and helped to build substantial capacity at the mid-career level preparing individuals for research leadership. The NIHR CLs themselves identified numerous benefits including having protected time for research, the flexibility of the award, the value of the ‘NIHR badge’ and the opportunities provided by NIHR for leadership development, mentorship, collaboration and networking.6 Over time, fill rates for CLs increased from 75% to 95% as ACFs completed PhDs and progressed through the pathway. 61% of NIHR CLs attained 4143 further funding awards and leveraged a total of £2,840,814,840. Within 5 years of completing their award, 95% of CLs remained research active with over 5700 publications, many of which impacted policy guidance and changes in practice.
In 2009, NIHR launched the NIHR Clinical Academic Training Programme. It was the first integrated clinical academic career pathway for NMAHPs in England and provided support at the doctoral, postdoctoral CL and senior CL levels. Those who were awarded funding were true pioneers and helped to expose the blocks and career challenges associated with a clinical academic career for NMAHP professions. A major obstacle was the difficulty for NHS organisations to manage the backfill for posts and also how to integrate individuals back into practice once academic awards ended. No structures were in place to manage the flow between clinical and academic environments and many felt isolated and misunderstood by their clinical colleagues. In addition, this was a new pathway and local research managers did not always understand the value of clinical academics let alone how best to support them. Much has changed since 2009, and many institutions have successfully navigated barriers and established an important stream of successful clinical academics, many of whom are now in leadership roles supporting the career development of the next generation. The NIHR has funded 4,902 NMAHPs since 2009 with numbers increasing substantially in the last 5 years and encompassing other professions such as healthcare scientists and pharmacists.
Key learning
Partnership
Maintaining strong relationships with strategic partners has been critical. NIHR established the Clinical Academic Training Forum which is led by partners and brings together stakeholders across the clinical academic training ecosystem. Partners share information and best practice, highlight and respond collectively to challenges and provide resources to those we fund. The CATCH website is an excellent example of this collective endeavour. It is co-funded through CATF members and acts as a careers Hub to provide advice and information about funding opportunities across the career pathway, events and other support such as access to mentorship.
Flexibility
Differences in professions and specialties and a constantly evolving landscape have required NIHR to be flexible. We adapted to continual changes in clinical training and provided additional support, such as bridging, to fellows when needed. It was often necessary to create bespoke pathways e.g. for general practitioners and dentists who needed a better fit with clinical training. For NMAHPs, the lack of backfill for clinical time made posts unattractive, so we increased funding for clinical lectureships to pay for clinical service. This avoided the need for backfill in overstretched organisations and allowed more clinical academics to apply and progress through careers.
Gaps
The NIHR set out to provide comprehensive career pathways for clinical academics, however, there were gaps that created disincentives and blocks to career progression. For medical and dental ACFs and CLs we did not provide project costs and encouraged our trainees to apply for their own. This was not an easy ask for those at the early stages of career and the Starter Grants for CLs provided by Academy of Medical Sciences, proved invaluable.6 For senior academics who had completed NIHR career pathways, we anticipated hosting organisations would provide ongoing career support and tenure. However, funding pressures meant that this was not always the case leading to what many have described as the ‘cliff edge’. Successful and sustainable career pathways require all partners to contribute. However, we saw inconsistency in funding provision and in some cases disinvestment, with some partners believing that support for clinical academics was largely NIHR’s responsibility.
Data
Collection of high-quality data has proved challenging. Stakeholders collect information in different formats and not everything is available or robust enough for use. Nonetheless, enough data paints a picture of what works well or needs attention, so that we can make changes to schemes and design interventions that we think will help. We wish we had collected more from the outset, but we now routinely collect application numbers, success rates, progression data (tracking through ResearchFish) research outputs and impact as well as data on protected characteristics. Partners are better at sharing these days and through CATF we have reviewed our collective support for clinical academics and shared resources, for example, co-funding for the UK Medical Education Database.
Inclusion
As the portfolio of clinical academics grew, we started to see some areas poorly represented. We introduced specific themes to grow some of the medical specialties and changed our eligibility to encourage more dentists. Applications from nurses were low with poorer success rates than other NMAHPs. We funded an NIHR Nursing Incubator to help bring confidence to the profession and improve the competitiveness of applications. This resulted in a doubling of the number of nurses awarded. Women progressing to senior roles was a particular concern, so we expanded medical and dental CL eligibility to include consultants which benefited women and increased numbers significantly. Current work is looking at other protected characteristics and support for new medical schools to improve diversity and geographical spread.
What next?
The clinical academic training landscape continues to evolve. Funding pressures are impacting universities, the NHS, charities and funders, reducing the availability of career opportunities. Changes in the clinical demographic has seen more women and ethnic minorities coming through and young trainees are increasingly considering the impact of academic careers on their standard of living and work/life balance. Despite our best efforts, many specialties and professions remain underrepresented. The Office for Strategic Coordination of Health Research (OSCHR) identified the need for further action to boost the numbers of clinical academics, which are not rising in line with the expansion in clinical posts. The OSCHR review published 2 reports7,8, with recommendations for action from stakeholders nationally. Work is currently underway and funders have mapped out and simplified all opportunities against the clinical academic training path so that applicants can easily see the best options for their stage of career. Many funders worked collaboratively to launch the Clinical Future Leaders Fellowship which is generously funded to support senior researchers with hosting organisations agreeing to long term support.
We are all aware of future challenges. The key will be to strengthen strategic partnerships, build on evidence, make better use of precious resources and value and celebrate our talented clinical academics. It is easy to be negative about the journey ahead, but we should not lose sight of how far we have come and how many of our fellows thank us for their rewarding career.
Conclusion
The creation of integrated clinical academic career pathways in England has been transformative, built significant research capacity and capability and launched the careers of many talented clinical academics. In considering the key enablers for success, strong strategic partnerships are critical especially when underpinned by evidence and a shared understanding. It is not just about linkages between organisations; it is about creating opportunities to build productive and sustainable relationships between the right people who understand the value of what we are doing. Secondly, taking a proactive approach to flexibility has allowed us to adapt to change, understand differences between groups and ensure pathways are comprehensive. It is important not to lose sight of our strategic ambitions and sometimes this requires us to change the rules. In terms of future challenges, we need greater diversity, research is better for it, but even when we are inclusive in our approach, underrepresentation can remain. Perhaps we must be more targeted as we move ahead, but if we continue to work together, despite the challenges, we can ensure that research remains a vibrant and essential part of clinical practice for the next generation.
References
- Medically- and dentally-qualified academic staff: recommendations for training the researchers and educators of the future. March 2005. https://www.ukcrc.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Medically_and_Dentally-qualified_Academic_Staff_Report.pdf
- Developing the best research professionals Qualified graduate nurses: recommendations for preparing and supporting clinical academic nurses of the future. August 2007. https://www.ukcrc.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Nurses-report-August-07-Web.pdf
- UK clinical academic training in medicine and dentistry: principles and obligations. March 2018. https://www.nihr.ac.uk/uk-clinical-academic-training-medicine-and-dentistry-principles-and-obligations-march-2018
- UK clinical academic training for nurses, midwives, AHPs and other health and care professionals: principle and obligations. March 2018. https://www.nihr.ac.uk/uk-clinical-academic-training-nurses-midwives-ahps-and-other-health-and-care-professionals-principles-and-obligations
- Clough S, Fenton J, Harris-Joseph H, et al. What impact has the NIHR Academic Clinical Fellowship (ACF) scheme had on clinical academic careers in England over the last 10 years?: A retrospective study. BMJ Open. 2017;7:e015722. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2016-015722.
- Stevenson C, Harris-Joseph H, Harper L, et al. Experience of an NIHR Clinical Lectureship (medical/dental) and the determining factors for a clinical academic career post lectureship: a mixed-method evaluation. BMJ Open. 2023;13(11):e070536. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2022-070536.
- Clinical researchers in the United Kingdom: Reversing the decline to improve population health and promote economic growth. January 2025. https://www.ukri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/MRC-290125-ClinicalResearchersReversingTheDecline.pdf
- Clinical researchers in the United Kingdom: Building capacity to improve population health and promote economic growth. July 2026.
- https://www.ukri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/MRC-250605-250515-MRC_Clincial-Researcher-Nursing_8.pdf
Article information
Authors
- Lisa CotterillNational Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR), AcademyCorresponding author · [email protected]
How to cite
Cotterill, L., 2026. Establishing Successful Integrated Clinical Academic Career Pathways in England: Two decades on, what did we learn?. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0581
Record
- Journal
- Medical Research Archives
- Issue
- Vol 14 No 10 (2026)
- Section
- Editorial
- Published
- 31 October 2026
- ISSN
- 2375-1924
- Downloads
- 80
Copyright and licence
Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.