Key findings

  • Three scalesof the Dynamic Affordance Trajectory Framework mapped onto midwifery: real-time attunement during labor, skill-building across a career and the perinatal continuum, and long-term professional identity
  • 15 yearswindow in which sources in English, Spanish and Portuguese were located through citation tracking, selected purposively for conceptual relevance
  • Twounevenly recognized trajectories for midwifery coexist in Mexico, traditional midwives (parteras) and university-trained professional midwifery

Abstract

Midwifery is a paradigmatic case of embodied, affective, and relational cognition, a midwife’s expertise consists in perceiving and acting on the shifting possibilities for action offered by a laboring woman’s body, emotions, and environment. The literature has described this expertise mainly as intuition or tacit knowledge, without a systematic account of how it is organized over time. This narrative theoretical review examines whether the Dynamic Affordance Trajectory Framework, a model of how behavior and identity are shaped by opportunities for action across short-, medium-, and long-term timescales, can provide such an account. Sources from embodied cognitive science, phenomenology, midwifery, nursing, and anthropology, published in English, Spanish, and Portuguese, were selected purposively for their conceptual relevance and analyzed by mapping findings on birth attendance onto the framework’s three temporal scales. The review proposes that the relationship between midwife and woman is best understood as a jointly constructed trajectory unfolding at three levels: real-time attunement during labor; skill-building across a midwife’s career and across pregnancy, birth, and the postpartum period; and long-term professional identity shaped by cultural narratives about birth. It further interprets humanized childbirth as the deliberate construction of an environment that supports calm, trust, and agency, and illustrates the model with the coexistence of traditional and professional midwifery in Mexico. The framework offers midwifery studies a systematic vocabulary for tacit expertise, while midwifery offers the framework a high-stakes domain for empirical testing. Implications for midwifery education, perinatal mental-health care, and health policy are outlined.

Introduction

Two apparently distant bodies of work converge on the same theoretical commitment, that cognition is not a private, cranium-bound computation but a relational achievement that emerges from the coupling of an agent, a body, and an environment.1,2 The first, the Dynamic Affordance Trajectory Framework (DATF),3 is a general theory of how affordances, the evolving opportunities for action that an environment offers a skilled agent, organize behavior and identity across multiple timescales, from the sub-second dynamics of perception and action to the decades-long sedimentation of habits into a life narrative.4,5 The second is the study of midwifery, a practice in which embodied cognition is not a metaphor but the substance of expertise, a midwife’s clinical judgment is inseparable from her capacity to read, in real time, the bodily, affective, and relational signals of a woman in labor.6,7

These two bodies of work have so far developed separately. The midwifery literature describes the midwife’s expertise mainly in the language of intuition, tacit knowledge, or “the art of catching babies,” without a systematic account of how that expertise is organized in time. The DATF offers such an account, but it has not yet been applied to a concrete clinical practice.

The aim of this narrative review is therefore to examine whether, and how, the three temporal scales of the DATF can organize what is known about embodied cognition in midwifery. The review is guided by one central question, which is how is a midwife’s expertise distributed across real-time attunement during labor, adaptation across a career and across the perinatal continuum, and long-term professional and cultural identity? Its scope is theoretical. It does not report new empirical data but reinterprets existing philosophical, clinical, and ethnographic literature; it focuses on birth attendance and the pregnancy–birth–postpartum continuum; and it uses midwifery in Mexico, where traditional and professional midwifery coexist, as an illustrative case rather than as an object of empirical study.

Section 2 describes the review design. Section 3 summarizes the concepts of affordances and embodied affectivity on which both bodies of work rely, and Section 4 introduces the DATF’s three temporal scales. Section 5, the core of the review, maps these scales onto midwifery practice. Sections 6 and 7 apply the resulting model to two areas in which it has practical consequences, humanized childbirth, understood as the construction of an affective niche, and the coexistence of traditional and professional midwifery in Mexico. Section 8 outlines implications for education, practice, and policy, and Section 9 concludes.

Methods

This article is a narrative theoretical review. Unlike a systematic review, it does not aim at exhaustive retrieval of studies or at a pooled estimate of effects; its goal is conceptual integration, that is, bringing two bodies of literature into contact and assessing whether the constructs of one can organize the findings of the other. This design suits the review question, which is interpretive rather than quantitative, and a literature that is spread across philosophy, cognitive science, nursing, midwifery, and anthropology, with heterogeneous methods and vocabularies.

Sources were selected purposively for their conceptual relevance to the review question rather than retrieved through a predefined database search. Two groups of sources were included. The first comprises work in ecological psychology, embodied and enactive cognitive science, and phenomenology on affordances, embodied affectivity, affective niches, skilled intentionality, and the temporality of behavior, including the publications in which the DATF was developed. The second comprises clinical, nursing, and social-science literature on embodied and humanized birth attendance, perinatal and postpartum care, the ethics of autonomy in maternity care, and traditional midwifery, with particular attention to Latin American sources. Publications in English, Spanish, and Portuguese were included. These sources were located through citation tracking in the last 15 years.

The analysis proceeded in three steps. First, the core constructs of the DATF (affordance trajectory, ontogenetic niche trajectory, the micro, meso, and macro scales, and affective niches) were extracted as an analytic lens. Second, claims and findings from the midwifery literature were assigned to the temporal scale at which the process they describe operates. Third, the resulting mapping was examined for points at which the framework clarifies the midwifery literature and for points at which midwifery challenges or extends the framework. Because selection was purposive and no formal quality appraisal was performed, the review makes no claim to completeness; its conclusions should be read as a theoretical proposal to be tested empirically rather than as a synthesis of evidence.

Affordances and Embodied Affectivity as a Shared Foundation

Both bodies of work begin from the Gibsonian premise that affordances are neither objective properties of the environment nor subjective projections of the perceiver, but relations between the abilities of an agent and the features of a situation.2,5,8 To perceive an affordance is to perceive directly what a situation permits for action, without first classifying or conceptualizing its constituents. Chemero’s dynamical reframing adds that affordances and abilities are in constant, real-time, causal interaction, continuously co-determining one another.5 What a situation affords therefore changes as the agent’s skills, affective state, and history of interaction change, a point on which both midwifery and the DATF3 depend.

Embodied affectivity adds a second layer. For Fuchs,9 emotions are not purely internal states but modes of perception that disclose the significance of situations, so that objects and events are perceived as threatening, promising, or reassuring; these are affective affordances. Emotions carry kinesthetic tendencies, such as leaning in or withdrawing, and bodily resonance that link the perceiver to the surrounding situation.10 Colombetti and Krueger11 and Maiese12 add that agents actively construct affective niches, arranging objects, people, and routines to sustain or regulate particular emotional states. This capacity to construct affective niches, rather than merely react to a given environment, is central both to identity formation in the DATF and to humanized birth attendance.

A third shared concept is skilled intentionality, developed by Van Dijk and Rietveld13 and applied to embodied cognition by Mojica and Gastelum-Vargas.14 Skillful engagement with affordances is guided by intrinsic norms oriented toward preserving personal identity and coherence, together with extrinsic social and material constraints. This normativity is affective at root, it expresses a form of care for maintaining coherent action within a shared practice. A midwife’s actions illustrate it clearly, since they are guided neither by abstract rules nor by pure instinct, but by a normative sensitivity to what a particular labor calls for, tempered by the norms of her profession, her institution, and her culture.

The Dynamic Affordance Trajectory Framework

The DATF is a multiscalar model that integrates short-term perception-action cycles, medium-term adaptive processes, and long-term sociocultural influences into a single account of how identity and behavior are shaped by the changing affordances an agent encounters over development.3 Two constructs anchor it. An affordance trajectory is the dynamic pattern of opportunities for action that unfolds over time within an environment, changing with movement, context, and the affective and intentional texture of an agent’s interactions.15 Such trajectories are cumulative, which means that earlier interactions shape the sensorimotor schemes and habits through which later affordances are perceived, and organisms anticipate affordances on the basis of a “current future” projected from the regularities of past interaction.16 The ontogenetic niche trajectory names the cumulative influence of physical, social, and cultural environments on development. It evolves as the organism learns and is reciprocally shaped by the organism’s developing abilities, in a relationship of continuous, non-linear interaction rather than one-directional determination.15

The DATF organizes these dynamics across three temporal scales. The micro scale concerns perception and action in real time, in which immediate sensory input guides intentionality and normative and affective constraints determine moment-to-moment responses. It operates through three nested levels, the elementary, the integrative, and the narrative,17,18 and is best modeled with dynamical systems theory, treating brain, body, and environment as a single system in which perceptual information is directly available without complex inferential mediation.19,20

The meso scale concerns adaptation over weeks or months, during which individuals refine skills through repeated interaction within changing social and material contexts. At this scale sensorimotor schemes are built and refined, and the ontogenetic niche trajectory becomes visible as a lived process of skill acquisition.21

The macro scale concerns identity formation over years or a lifetime, in which sociocultural practices and historical narratives shape norms and affective responses. A key concept here is “affordative space,” the range of possibilities that emerges through movement and environmental change, which treats anatomical structure, developmental parameters, and social and normative practice as facets of a single ontogenetic niche.22 Habits, understood as embodied, pre-reflective coordinative structures, are the vehicle through which affordative space becomes lived identity, performing a habit reshapes the body-environment system so that the same pattern is more likely to recur, stabilizing personal and collective identity over time.23

Crucially, the three scales are interdependent. Immediate perceptions and actions accumulate into meso-scale adaptations, which sediment into macro-scale identity; reciprocally, long-term identities and cultural narratives shape which affordances are salient at the micro scale in the first place. Agency and identity are thus distributed across temporal scales rather than located at any one of them.24–26 It is this feedback architecture, and not the three scales taken separately, that the next section applies to midwifery.

Midwifery as an Affordance Trajectory

Embodied cognition in birth attendance

Embodied cognition suits midwifery because it rejects the picture of clinical knowledge as an abstract process running independently of the body. A midwife’s knowledge is anchored in the sensory and motor experience of her own body and in continuous interaction with the environment and with the woman in labor.6 Through her body schema and kinesthetic perception, she interprets the subtle signals of the laboring woman and responds adaptively to a physiological process that does not follow a fixed script.7 This ranges from reading contractions and cervical dilation to attending to facial expression and breathing, revealing a form of intelligence that is practical, sensorimotor, affective, and relational rather than propositional. Nourished by attentive observation and empathy, it amounts to a dynamic choreography between expert knowledge and informed improvisation.27

Midwifery skills are refined not only through formal training but through the accumulation of embodied experience that shapes intuition and clinical judgment.28 Non-verbal communication, touch, and empathy are constitutive of the practice, since the quality of interaction between caregiver and laboring woman influences maternal perception and neurohormonal processes during labor.7,29 Through the lens of the DATF, what this literature calls intuition and tacit skill can be redescribed as an affordance trajectory, a dynamically evolving field of possibilities for action that midwife and laboring woman jointly constitute and that neither could constitute alone.

The micro scale: attunement in real time

At the micro scale, immediate sensory input, such as a change in breathing rhythm, a shift in posture, or tension around the eyes, guides a response that must occur within seconds rather than deliberative minutes. What the midwife perceives are social affordances as relations between her own perceptual-motor abilities and the momentary state of the woman’s body and affect.30 This is not inferential diagnosis in the sense of applying a general rule to a particular case. On the ecological account, perceptual information is structured and specific, so the midwife can directly perceive what a contraction, a posture, or a sound affords without first classifying it under a diagnostic category.8,16

The constant non-verbal interaction between midwife and laboring woman generates a field of affective information that enables fine-grained attunement to the needs of the moment.31 As the midwife adjusts her position, offers a hand, or modulates her voice, she does not merely respond to a fixed situation but reshapes the affordances available to the woman in the next moment of labor, and vice versa. Her actions participate in constituting the very field of affordances she is reading.

The meso scale: adaptation across a career and across the perinatal continuum

In midwifery, the meso scale operates on at least two nested timeframes. The first is a single pregnancy–birth–postpartum continuum, which the literature increasingly frames as one vital continuum in which care must be shaped to individual needs across gestation, birth, and the “fourth trimester” of postpartum recovery.32,33 In DATF terms, this continuum is a developmental niche for the mother-infant dyad, in which physical, social, and affective resources accumulate across gestation and postpartum and continue to shape the mother’s affordance landscape well beyond hospital discharge.34,35

The second timeframe is the midwife’s professional development. Her clinical judgment is built through embodied experience across many labors, each refining her sensitivity to the affordances offered by different bodies, affective states, and cultural contexts.28,36 On this reading, what the literature calls “intuition” denotes not an extra-rational faculty but the sedimentation of an affordance trajectory into refined perceptual and motor sensitivity. This helps explain why continuous, high-quality interaction between provider and laboring woman is associated with better outcomes and higher maternal satisfaction,37,38 not because it follows a better protocol, but because it constitutes a richer, more responsive affordance landscape for both parties across the whole arc of care.

The macro scale: professional identity and cultural narratives of birth

At the macro scale, midwifery identity is shaped by at least three interacting sets of norms, the biomedical model of obstetric care, the humanized-birth movement, and, in contexts such as Mexico, traditional midwifery. The biomedical model tends to depersonalize birth and can disempower women when their preferences are subordinated to institutional protocol and professional authority.39,40 The humanized-birth movement, advanced by nursing professionals and feminist social movements alike, reframes birth as a holistic experience with physical, emotional, and sociocultural dimensions, and insists on the woman’s right to choose her position, to have companions present, and to participate in decisions about her own labor.41–43

In DATF terms, these are competing affordative spaces, competing configurations of what a birth setting makes available for action, and therefore competing molds for the kind of midwife, and the kind of laboring woman, that an institutional culture will produce over time. Traditional midwifery in Mexico, discussed in Section 7, is a third such space, in which knowledge transmitted across generations integrates physical care with herbal practice, massage, and emotional and spiritual support, anticipating in important respects the vocabulary of embodied cognition.44,45

Affective Niches and the Humanization of Birth

The DATF’s treatment of affective niches gives conceptual precision to what the midwifery literature calls humanization. An affective niche is a configuration of interactions that enables certain emotional states, actively constructed by agents who manipulate their surroundings rather than enduring whatever affective tone the environment happens to have.11,12 Corris46 generalizes this into the notion of affective environments, objects, information, or people that influence thought, feeling, and action, in line with Sterelny’s view47 that environmental scaffolding is a vital contributor to the evolution of mental capacities.

Read through this lens, the practices grouped under humanized birth, such as the freedom to choose a position, the presence of a chosen companion, continuous emotional support, and unhurried communication, are not comfort measures added to a medically sufficient birth. They are the joint construction, by midwife and woman, of an affective niche that sustains calm, trust, and a felt sense of agency, which in turn make certain physiological and behavioral affordances available, easier labor progress, more effective use of endogenous coping resources, and reduced perceived pain and trauma.7,48 Because affect and affordance are two faces of the same relation, shaping the affective environment of birth is shaping what the woman can perceive as available to her in that moment.

The same reframing clarifies why poor postpartum care causes harm. The postpartum period is a time of major hormonal and physiological change and a critical window for adaptation to motherhood, yet it has been historically undervalued in practice, research, and training.33 Inadequate postpartum support represents a collapse of the affective niche at the meso scale, precisely where the new mother most needs it; unmet needs, anxiety, and postpartum depression are then a predictable consequence of withdrawing that scaffolding rather than incidental side effects.34,49

Finally, the reciprocity between affordances and abilities bears on the much-discussed tension between a woman’s autonomy and the institutional authority of health professionals.40,50 If affordances and abilities are co-determining, a model of informed consent that treats the woman as a passive recipient of information misdescribes the phenomenon it aims to regulate. An embodied account of shared decision-making would instead track how her evolving perceptions, expressed preferences, and bodily signals continuously reshape what the midwife should, and can, do next, and vice versa.51

Midwifery in Mexico. Coexisting Ontogenetic Niches

Mexico illustrates, at the macro scale, the coexistence of two unevenly recognized ontogenetic niche trajectories for midwifery. Traditional midwives, or parteras, have for centuries offered culturally sensitive and accessible care, especially in rural and indigenous communities. Their knowledge, transmitted across generations, integrates birth technique with herbal medicine, massage, and emotional, spiritual, and communal support, reflecting a holistic understanding of maternal-infant wellbeing that is continuous with the embodied account developed in Section 5.44 Professional midwifery, by contrast, has been formalized through university programs and integration into health institutions, aligning care with biomedical protocols. Their coexistence is an opportunity to combine culturally rooted expertise with evidence-based practice, as the DATF’s notion of a single but internally differentiated affordative space would recommend, rather than treating one trajectory as superseding the other.

This coexistence is compounded by structural disadvantage. Postpartum care in Mexico is not always adequately prioritized, leading to weak policy and insufficient follow-up for new mothers,52 a critical gap given the high rates of postpartum anxiety and depression reported globally.49 Poverty and inadequate access to health services increase the risk of postpartum complications such as depression, obesity, and hemorrhage, underscoring the need for community-embedded postpartum programs.53 Traditional beliefs about heat and cold or postpartum confinement shape maternal recovery in many cultures, including Otomí and Mazahua communities in Mexico, and ethnopharmacological research has begun to validate the use of traditional plant-based resources.45,54

Framed through the DATF, the Mexican case is not only a question of resource allocation but of which ontogenetic niche trajectory, and therefore which affordative space, mothers and midwives are permitted to inhabit. A system organized only around biomedical protocol constrains the affordances available to traditional midwives and the women they serve, foreclosing culturally meaningful sources of affective scaffolding, such as herbal knowledge, kinship-based postpartum support, and community ritual, that the DATF predicts to be causally relevant to maternal outcomes rather than incidental to them.

Implications for Education, Practice, and Health Policy

The original DATF proposal suggested applications to education, therapy, and community planning;3 the case of midwifery sharpens each. In education, programs that treat clinical judgment as protocol acquisition alone neglect the meso-scale, experience-dependent process through which sensitivity to social and affective affordances is built. Guided, reflective exposure to a wide range of embodied interactions would better track how expertise is acquired, consistent with findings that experiential, non-verbal, and affective competencies are as central to good outcomes as technical skill.28,29

In practice, a biopsychosocial and embodied model of perinatal care involving midwives, psychologists, psychiatrists, and social workers is needed to address both the biological complexity and the affective-corporeal context of maternity.55,56 Because affect, habit, and identity operate across interlocking timescales, perinatal mental-health screening should be an ongoing meso-scale process attuned to each stage of the perinatal continuum rather than a single time-point assessment.57,58

In policy, recognizing midwifery, in both its traditional and professional forms, as an affordance-constituting practice rather than a service delivered to a passive patient provides a principled basis for valuing culturally rooted care work, remunerating it equitably, and integrating it into public health planning rather than treating it as a pre-modern survival to be phased out.59,60 Likewise, institutional design that allows freedom of movement and position in labor, permits companionship, and reduces unnecessary intervention follows from treating birth settings as affordative spaces with macro-scale consequences for identity, wellbeing, and trust in the health system.61

Conclusion

This review has argued that bringing the DATF into contact with the embodied-cognition literature on midwifery is mutually clarifying. The framework gains a concrete, high-stakes domain in which its micro, meso, and macro architecture can be tested against a substantial body of empirical and ethnographic work. Midwifery studies gain a vocabulary that goes beyond describing expert judgment as “intuition” or “art,” specifying the temporal grain of each component of a midwife’s expertise, real-time attunement to bodily and affective signals during labor (micro scale); the accumulation of judgment across a career and across the pregnancy–birth–postpartum continuum (meso scale); and the formation of professional and cultural identity within contested narratives about what birth is and who should attend it (macro scale).

The synthesis also has a normative upshot. If affordances and abilities are co-constituted in real time, humanizing birth is not an optional layer of comfort added to a sufficient clinical encounter but the construction of the affective and material niche within which a woman’s own capacities for labor become available to her. And if identity is shaped by ontogenetic niche trajectories that extend across generations and cultures, a health system that recognizes only the biomedical trajectory forecloses affordances that matter, as the Mexican case makes vivid, for the health, dignity, and autonomy of mothers and midwives alike.

As a narrative theoretical review based on purposively selected sources, this work proposes a model rather than testing it. Two lines of research could do so, observational or ethnographic studies designed to track affordance trajectories during labor, treating midwife and woman as a single, jointly constituted perception-action system; and comparative work across midwifery traditions, using the concepts of affordative space and ontogenetic niche trajectory to analyze how institutional and cultural configurations of birth attendance shape, and are shaped by, the identities of the women and practitioners involved.

Declarations

Funding
This paper was funded by DGAPA-UNAM Project number IA400524 “Interculturalidad en las prácticas científicas y tecnológicas: configuraciones de comportamiento y racionalidades”.

References

  1. Favela LH, Chemero A. The animal-environment system. In: Coello Y, Fischer MH, eds. Perceptual and Emotional Embodiment. Routledge; 2015:67-82.
  2. Gibson J. The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1979.
  3. Gastelum-Vargas M. Trajectories of being: how affordances shape identity and behavior across time. Topoi. 2026;45:427-439. doi:10.1007/s11245-025-10257-6
  4. Gastelum M. Scale matters: temporality in the perception of affordances. Front Psychol. 2020;11:1188.
  5. Chemero A. Radical Embodied Cognitive Science. MIT Press; 2009.
  6. Battán Horenstein A. La centralidad de la noción de esquema corporal como quiasmo de espacio y movimiento. Investigaciones Fenomenológicas. 2014;(10):15-32.
  7. Olza I, Uvnäs-Moberg K, Ekström-Bergström A, et al. Birth as a neuro-psycho-social event: an integrative model of maternal experiences and their relation to neurohormonal events during childbirth. PLoS One. 2020;15(7):e0230992.
  8. Chemero A. An outline of a theory of affordances. Ecol Psychol. 2003;15(2):181-195.
  9. Fuchs T. Embodied interaffectivity and psychopathology. In: Szanto T, Landweer H, eds. The Routledge Handbook of Phenomenology of Emotion. Routledge; 2020.
  10. Fuchs T, Koch SC. Embodied affectivity: on moving and being moved. Front Psychol. 2014;5:508.
  11. Colombetti G, Krueger J. Scaffoldings of the affective mind. Philos Psychol. 2015;28(8):1157-1176.
  12. Maiese M. How can emotions be both cognitive and bodily? Phenomenol Cogn Sci. 2014;13:513-531.
  13. Van Dijk L, Rietveld E. Foregrounding sociomaterial practice in our understanding of affordances: the skilled intentionality framework. Front Psychol. 2017;7:1969.
  14. Mojica L, Gastelum-Vargas M. The affective and normative intentionality of skilled performance: a radical embodied approach. Synthese. 2021;199(3-4):8205-8230.
  15. Cadena-Alvear I, Gastelum-Vargas M. Examining behavioral settings and affordative space for the case of autism spectrum conditions in embodied cognition. Philos Psychol. 2024;37(7):1797-1827.
  16. Heras-Escribano M, Travieso D, Lobo L. An affordance-based approach to the origins of concepts. In: Mangalam M, Hajnal A, Kelty-Stephen DG, eds. The Modern Legacy of Gibson’s Affordances for the Sciences of Organisms. Routledge; 2024:83-100.
  17. Gallagher S. Husserl and the phenomenology of temporality. In: Dyke H, Bardon A, eds. A Companion to the Philosophy of Time. Wiley-Blackwell; 2013:135-150.
  18. Varela FJ. The specious present: a neurophenomenology of time consciousness. In: Petitot J, Varela FJ, Pachoud B, Roy JM, eds. Naturalizing Phenomenology. Stanford University Press; 1999:266-314.
  19. Kirchhoff MD. Extended cognition and the causal-constitutive fallacy: in search for a diachronic and dynamical conception of constitution. Philos Phenomenol Res. 2015;90:320-360.
  20. Raja V, Anderson ML. Behavior considered as an enabling constraint. In: Calzavarini F, Viola M, eds. Neural Mechanisms: New Challenges in the Philosophy of Neuroscience. Springer; 2021:209-232.
  21. Baggs E. All affordances are social: foundations of a Gibsonian social ontology. Ecol Psychol. 2021;33(3-4):257-278.
  22. Gallagher S, Ranson T. Artifacting minds: material engagement theory and joint action. In: Tewes C, ed. Embodiment in Evolution and Culture. de Gruyter; 2016:337-351.
  23. Loaiza JM, Trasmundi SB, Steffensen SV. Multiscalar temporality in human behaviour: a case study of constraint interdependence in psychotherapy. Front Psychol. 2020;11:1685.
  24. Chemero A. Intertwined Creatures: The Embodied Cognitive Science of Self and Other. Columbia University Press; 2025.
  25. Dengsø MJ, Kirchhoff MD. Beyond individual-centered 4E cognition: systems biology and sympoiesis. Constr Found. 2023;18(3):351-364.
  26. Haraway DJ. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press; 2016.
  27. Neiterman E. Doing pregnancy: pregnant embodiment as performance. Womens Stud Int Forum. 2012;35(5):372-383.
  28. Magno C, Silva P, dos Santos M et al. A enfermagem na humanização do parto: uma revisão integrativa da literatura. Res Soc Dev. 2022;11(3).
  29. Santos de Oliveira P, Menezes T, Matos G, et al. Obstetric nurse and the factors that influence care in the delivery process. Rev Gaucha Enferm. 2021;42.
  30. Felisian S, Mushy SE, Tarimo E, Kibusi SM. Sociocultural practices and beliefs during pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum among indigenous pastoralist women in Manyara, Tanzania. BMC Womens Health. 2023;23(1).
  31. Sarmiento I, Paredes-Solís S, Loutfi D, Dion A, Cockcroft A, Andersson N. Fuzzy cognitive mapping and soft models of indigenous knowledge on maternal health in Guerrero, Mexico. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2020;20.
  32. Maputle MS. A woman-centred childbirth model. Health SA. 2010;15(1).
  33. Shaik A, Khan S, Shaik A, Shaik K. Advancements in postpartum rehabilitation: a systematic review. Cureus. 2024.
  34. Almalik M. Understanding maternal postpartum needs: a descriptive survey of current maternal health services. J Clin Nurs. 2017;26(23-24):4654-4663.
  35. Lambermon FJ, Vandenbussche F, Dedding C, Van Duijnhoven N. Maternal self-care in the early postpartum period: an integrative review. Midwifery. 2020;90:102799.
  36. Ribeiro S. Cultura nas instituições de saúde e suas relações com a identidade individual. Cogitare Enferm. 2007;12(2).
  37. Vasconcellos C, Könzgen SM, Correa M, Pieren dos Reis S, Heck RM. Experiências vivenciadas pela mulher no momento do parto e nascimento de seu filho. Cogitare Enferm. 2009;14(3).
  38. Svenningsen IK, Almeida T. Embodying the emotional pregnancy: design explorations of a prenatal yoga multi-sensorial environment. In: OzCHI ’20: Proceedings of the 32nd Australian Conference on Human-Computer Interaction. ACM; 2020.
  39. Souza TG de, Muhnoz M, Siniak P. A humanização do nascimento: percepção dos profissionais de saúde que atuam na atenção ao parto. Rev Gaucha Enferm. 2011;32(3).
  40. Diorgu F, George AN. Broader driver of disrespectful maternity care: power dynamics. Obstet Gynecol Int J. 2021;12(3):130.
  41. Kennedy HP. The midwife as an “instrument” of care. Am J Public Health. 2002;92(11):1759-1760.
  42. Pires Moura F, Delgado C, Sampaio I, et al. A humanização e a assistência de enfermagem ao parto normal. Rev Bras Enferm. 2007;60(4).
  43. Araújo R, Lenho de Figueiredo A, Amaral J, Oliveira RJ. Discursive practices about the decision-making power of women in childbirth. Interface (Botucatu). 2022;26.
  44. Dennis C, Fung K, Grigoriadis S, Robinson GE, Romans S, Ross LE. Traditional postpartum practices and rituals: a qualitative systematic review. Womens Health (Lond). 2007;3(4):487-502.
  45. Rodríguez-Zúñiga J, Ávila-Nájera DM, Mora-Garduño LC, Tovar-Martínez R, Bautista-Santos H, Sánchez-Galván F. Midwifery and medicinal plants in the Mazahua and Otomi indigenous group of the state of Mexico. Soc Sci. 2023;12(10):542.
  46. Corris A. Affective scaffolding in nature. Philos Psychol. Published online 2024.
  47. Sterelny K. Minds: extended or scaffolded? Phenomenol Cogn Sci. 2010;9(4):465-481.
  48. Paiva de Almeida P, Becker L, Lindner V, Zveiter M. The use of your own voice in labor: a phenomenological study. Rev Gaucha Enferm. 2022;43.
  49. Liu Y, Guo N, Li T, Zhuang W, Jiang H. Prevalence and associated factors of postpartum anxiety and depression symptoms among women in Shanghai, China. J Affect Disord. 2020;274:848-856.
  50. Wilkinson D, Teli S, Litchfield C, et al. Ethics round table: choice and autonomy in obstetrics. J Med Ethics. 2025;51:588-592.
  51. Kingma E. Harming one to benefit another: the paradox of autonomy and consent in maternity care. Bioethics. 2021;35(5):456-464.
  52. Magill-Cuerden J. Postnatal care in the home setting: essential support after birth. Br J Midwifery. 2006;14(1).
  53. Ding G, Yu J, Vinturache A, Gu H, Lu M. Therapeutic effects of the traditional “doing the month” practices on postpartum depression in China. Am J Psychiatry. 2018;175(11):1071.
  54. Sibeko L, Johns T, Cordeiro L. Traditional plant use during lactation and postpartum recovery: infant development and maternal health roles. J Ethnopharmacol. 2021;279:114377.
  55. Buultjens M, Murphy G, Robinson P, Milgrom J. The perinatal period: a literature review from the biopsychosocial perspective. Clin Nurs Stud. 2013;1(3).
  56. Duberstein ZT, Brunner J, Panisch LS, Bandyopadhyay S, Irvine C, Macri JA, Pressman E, Thornburg LL, Poleshuck E, Bell K, Best M, Barrett E, Miller RK and O'Connor TG (2021) The Biopsychosocial Model and Perinatal Health Care: Determinants of Perinatal Care in a Community Sample. Front. Psychiatry 12:746803. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.746803
  57. Johnson J, Hope L, Jones L, Bradley E. A mixed methods study to understand perinatal mental healthcare referral decisions among midwives and health visitors in the UK. Front Psychiatry. 2023;14.
  58. Flynn H, Hansen M, Shabaka-Haynes A, Chapman S, Ross KR. Implementation of a multi-component behavioral health integration program in obstetrics for perinatal behavioral health. Front Psychiatry. 2021;12.
  59. Galindo Vilchis LM. Cuidar: una aproximación desde la epistemología del Sur. Revista Ñanduty. 2019; 7(11):208-228.
  60. Carbó GFC, García-Orellán R. Burden and gender inequalities around informal care. Invest Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1).
  61. Juanillo-Maluenda H, Sánchez-Bandala MA. ¿Por qué preocuparnos de los cuidados y de su visibilización en la sociedad? Rev Salud Publica. 2018;22(3):89.

Article information

Authors

How to cite

Gastelum-Vargas, M., 2026. Affordances in midwifery across time: a narrative review of embodied and affective care. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0684

Record

Journal
Medical Research Archives
Section
Research Articles
Published
31 October 2026
ISSN
2375-1924
Downloads
80

Copyright and licence

Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.