Key findings

  • 72,831children and adults aged 2 years and older in NHANES 2001–2018 whose diets were modeled
  • +5.52 and +4.52HEI-2015 points in children and adults when one serving of baked beans replaced protein foods (p < 0.0001)
  • +161–162 mgpotassium per serving with protein food replacement, alongside more iron, calcium, magnesium and fiber
  • +151 and +175 mgdaily sodium in children and adults when one serving replaced protein foods; mixing in canned beans lowered the rise to +125 and +147 mg

Abstract

Background
Baked beans are a widely consumed, affordable, and nutrient-dense food that provide dietary fiber, protein, iron, potassium, magnesium, and calcium. Although baked beans contain modest amounts of added sugar and sodium from commercial preparation, their comprehensive nutritional profile supports their inclusion in health-promoting dietary patterns. Limited research has modeled the nutritional impact of replacing commonly consumed food groups with baked beans across the children and adults.
Aims
To examine changes in nutrient intakes and Healthy Eating Index-2015 (HEI-2015) diet quality scores when commonly consumed food groups are isocalorically replaced with baked beans alone or with a combination of baked beans and canned beans, in children aged 2–18 years and adults ≥19 years. Methods: Dietary data from NHANES 2001–2018 (N=72,831; age ≥2 years) were used to conduct an analysis where two isocaloric replacement exposures were modeled: baked beans alone (RACC=130 g) and baked beans combined with canned beans (RACC=90 g each), substituted for protein foods, white potatoes, starchy foods, vegetables, and all foods at up to one or two servings.
Results
All replacement scenarios significantly improved HEI-2015 total scores in both age groups. Replacing protein foods with one serving of baked beans produced the largest improvements (children: +5.52 points; adults: +4.52 points), driven by gains in Greens and Beans (+2.75 and +2.47 points) and Seafood and Plant Protein (+2.18 and +1.81 points) components. Baked bean replacement consistently increased potassium (+161–162 mg/d), iron (+1.44–1.45 mg/d), calcium (+34–35 mg/d), magnesium (+21–22 mg/d), and dietary fiber (+4.5–4.7 g/d), and reduced saturated fat (−1.66 to −1.73 g/d) and cholesterol (−43 to −51 mg/d) per serving. The combination of baked beans and canned beans produced modestly superior HEI improvements, primarily through reduced net sodium intake (−25 to −27 mg/serving) higher folate (+3 µg/serving), and slightly higher dietary fiber (+0.15 g /serving), while further reducing the added sugar increment. Replacing all foods produced the greatest HEI gains (children: +8.52 to +8.81 points; adults: +6.40 to +6.64 points).
Conclusion
Baked beans are a nutritionally valuable food whose modest added sugar content is more than offset by substantial contributions to shortfall nutrient intakes and diet quality. Isocaloric substitution of baked beans for protein foods, white potatoes, starchy foods, or vegetables significantly improves diet quality and key shortfall nutrient intakes in U.S. children and adults. Public health guidance should promote baked beans as a practical, affordable, and evidence-based dietary strategy for improving the American dietary pattern.

Introduction

Legumes, including dry beans, lentils, peas, and canned beans are consistently recognized by the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) and international dietary authorities as key components of health-promoting dietary patterns.1,2 Substantial epidemiological and clinical evidence links legume consumption to reduced risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, colorectal cancer, and all-cause mortality, mediated through effects on serum lipid profiles, glycemic control, blood pressure, body weight, and gut microbiome composition.3–12 Despite these well-documented benefits, the vast majority of Americans fail to meet DGA recommendations for legume intake, with mean consumption falling well below the recommended 1.5 cups per week.1,13,14

Baked beans, including commercially prepared navy or haricot beans in a sweetened tomato-based sauce, occupy a distinctive and somewhat underappreciated position within the legume food category. Unlike plain canned beans or dry-cooked beans, baked beans contain modest amounts of added sugar (approximately 1.6 teaspoon equivalents [tsp eq], or about 6.8 g, per 130 g serving) and sodium (approximately 488 mg per serving) arising from their sauce and seasoning. These nutritional characteristics have occasionally led clinicians and public health communicators to treat baked beans with more caution than other legume forms, despite the substantial nutritional density contributed. Per 130 g serving, baked beans provide approximately 6.5 g of protein, 5.7 g of dietary fiber, 347.5 mg of potassium, 2.44 mg of iron, 57.6 mg of calcium, 40.9 mg of magnesium, and 26.0 µg of folate, nutrients collectively identified by previous dietary guidelines as chronically underconsumed in the U.S. population.1,15–18

Baked beans have been associated in observational research with improved health outcomes in ways that are not negated by their sodium and added sugar content. Previous analyses using data from the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) 1999–2002 demonstrated adults consuming baked beans had significantly lower systolic blood pressure compared to non-consumers, a finding that persisted even in the context of higher sodium intakes. Further, baked bean consumption was associated with reduced intake of discretionary fat and added sugars at the total diet.19 More recently, bean dietary patterns inclusive of baked beans have been associated with significantly higher HEI-2015 diet quality scores and greater intakes of multiple shortfall nutrients in nationally representative adult samples,20,21 further providing consideration that the net nutritional contribution of baked beans within healthy dietary patterns may exceed the modest concern of added sugar and sodium content when evaluated in the context of total diet quality.

Dietary modeling analyses using NHANES data have become a well-established methodology for quantifying the nutritional consequences of population-level dietary substitutions without the confounding inherent in observational designs. Such analyses have been applied to tree nuts, legumes, eggs, and grain foods, consistently demonstrating that isocaloric substitution of nutrient-dense foods for commonly consumed alternatives improves shortfall nutrient delivery and overall diet quality.13,22,23 However, prior modeling studies examining bean substitution have focused primarily on canned beans or combined bean categories,21,24 without separately examining baked beans as a distinct food type, and none have examined these effects in children and adolescents.

Within the present analysis two replacement exposures are modeled simultaneously: (1) baked beans alone and (2) baked beans combined with canned beans, allowing direct quantification of the incremental benefits of combining bean types. The specific aim is to determine whether isocaloric replacement of five commonly consumed food groups with baked beans, or with baked beans and canned beans combined, improves HEI-2015 diet quality scores and shortfall nutrient intakes in U.S. children and adults, and to contextualize the added sugar and sodium contributions of baked beans within the broader nutritional benefit profile of these substitution scenarios.

Methods

Data source and analytic sample

This cross-sectional dietary modeling analysis used publicly available dietary data from NHANES 2001–2018, encompassing nine two-year survey cycles (2001–2002, 2003-2004, 2005-2006, 2007-2008, 2009-2010, 2011-2012, 2013-2014, 2015-2016 and 2017–2018). NHANES is a nationally representative, continuous survey of the non-institutionalized U.S. civilian population conducted by the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), using a complex, stratified, multistage probability sampling design.25 Dietary intake data were collected via the Automated Multiple-Pass Method (AMPM), a validated five-step interviewer-administered 24-hour dietary recall.26 Nutrient values were assigned using the USDA Food and Nutrient Database for Dietary Studies (FNDDS) for the applicable survey cycle, and food group equivalents were derived from the Food Patterns Equivalents Database (FPED).27

The initial sample included all individuals aged 2 years and older with available Day 1 dietary recall data. Individuals were excluded if they had incomplete or unreliable dietary recall data, were pregnant or lactating, or reported consuming zero foods on the recall day. The final analytic sample after exclusions comprised N=72,831 individuals. Analyses were conducted separately for children aged 2–18 years and adults aged ≥19 years.

Bean definitions and nutritional profiles

Baked beans were identified by specific FNDDS food codes corresponding to commercially prepared baked beans (primarily navy beans in sweetened tomato sauce), with a RACC of 130 grams. Canned beans were defined as USDA food category 2802 entries with 'canned' in the description, excluding refried beans, with a RACC of 90 grams. An 'all beans' food type combining baked and canned bean food codes was also constructed for the combination replacement scenario. Nutritional profiles for each food type were derived as survey-weighted means per RACC across all consumption events in the NHANES individual food files (IFF) among subjects in the analytic sample.

Food groups for replacement

Five food group replacement scenarios were constructed, with both baked beans and canned beans excluded from each target food group: (1) Protein foods (USDA main group 2); (2) White potatoes (USDA subgroup 68); (3) Starchy foods (USDA subgroup 68 or category 6418); (4) Vegetables (USDA main group 7); and (5) All foods (any USDA group). Nutritional profiles of each replacement food group were derived as survey-weighted means per RACC across consumption events in the analytic sample.

Isocaloric replacement methodology

For each replacement scenario, nutrients from the target food group were removed from each subject's daily intake in proportion to the serving(s) replaced, and nutrients from baked beans (or baked beans plus canned beans) were added back at equivalent caloric value. For subjects consuming less than one RACC of the target food group, all nutrients from that group were removed and replaced by the proportional caloric equivalent in beans. For subjects consuming more than one RACC when up to one serving was to be replaced, the fraction corresponding to one RACC was removed and replaced. This procedure was applied at one and two serving levels. All analyses were restricted to habitual consumers of the replacement food group (i.e., individuals who consumed the target food group on their recall day). Total daily energy intake was preserved throughout.

Outcome variables and statistical analysis

Primary outcomes were changes in 27 nutrients and HEI-2015 total and component scores (13 components). Consistent with FPED, added sugars are expressed in teaspoon equivalents (tsp eq; 1 tsp eq = 4.2 g). HEI-2015 was calculated before and after replacement for each subject using FPED-derived food group equivalents. All analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC) with PROC SURVEYREG, incorporating complex survey parameters and two-day dietary sample weights, consistent with NCHS analytical guidelines.25,28 Survey-weighted least squares means, standard errors, and delta values (adjusted minus baseline) were estimated for each scenario. All delta values were statistically significant at p<0.0001.

Results

The per-RACC nutritional profiles of baked beans, canned beans, and the five replacement food groups are presented in Table 1. HEI-2015 total and component scores are summarized in Tables 2 and 4 and key nutrient intakes are shown in Table 3 following isocaloric replacement with baked beans alone or combined with canned beans, among children aged 2–18 years and adults aged ≥19 years.

Nutritional profiles of baked beans and replacement food groups

Per 130 g RACC, baked beans provide 130.2 kcal, 6.5 g protein, 5.7 g dietary fiber, 347.5 mg potassium, 2.44 mg iron, 57.6 mg calcium, 40.9 mg magnesium, 26.0 µg folate DFE, 0.34 g saturated fat, 4.3 mg cholesterol, 9.0 g total sugars, and 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) added sugars. The sodium content of baked beans is 488.3 mg per RACC, reflecting the tomato-based sauce in commercial preparations (Table 1).

Table 1. Nutritional Profile per Reference Amount Customarily Consumed (RACC) of Baked Beans, Canned Beans, and Food Groups Available for Isocaloric Replacement, NHANES 2001–2018

Nutrient / ParameterBaked Beans
(130 g RACC)
Canned Beans
(90 g RACC)
Protein Foods
(per RACC)
White Potatoes
(per RACC)
Starchy Foods
(per RACC)
Vegetables
(per RACC)
All Foods
(per RACC)
Energy (kcal)130.2138.5157.7171.2168.180.8108.9
Protein (g)6.57.213.52.62.71.74.1
Total Carbohydrate (g)26.421.03.922.922.911.613.4
Dietary Fiber (g)5.77.50.72.12.21.90.8
Total Fat (g)1.33.29.77.97.63.54.2
Saturated Fat (g)0.340.492.681.931.850.801.38
Total Sugars (g)9.01.30.81.21.52.06.2
Added Sugars (tsp eq)1.620.000.090.020.020.040.96
Potassium (mg)347.5371.8207.5389.0383.8250.9132.7
Iron (mg)2.442.201.040.610.650.540.77
Folate DFE (µg)26.056.616.915.717.527.427.5
Calcium (mg)57.651.424.424.824.924.249.7
Magnesium (mg)40.944.522.123.123.717.114.6
Sodium (mg)488.3261.0365.4271.8268.4159.0178.4
Cholesterol (mg)4.30.0371.75.45.12.214.2

RACC = reference amount customarily consumed; tsp eq = teaspoon equivalents (1 tsp eq = 4.2 g).

Baked beans compare favorably to all five replacement food groups for saturated fat, contain less cholesterol than every replacement group except vegetables, exceed protein foods, vegetables, and all foods for potassium, and exceed all five groups for iron and calcium. The starchy foods profile closely resembled that of white potatoes (168.1 vs. 171.2 kcal and 383.8 vs. 389.0 mg potassium per RACC), reflecting the predominance of white potatoes within this category. Relative to canned beans, baked beans provide more iron (2.44 vs. 2.20 mg/RACC) and more calcium (57.6 vs. 51.4 mg) per RACC, but considerably less folate (26.0 vs. 56.6 µg), reflecting the different bean varieties and processing characteristics. Baked beans contribute meaningfully more sodium than any of the replacement food groups, including protein foods (488.3 vs. 365.4 mg per RACC), and unlike canned beans contribute 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) of added sugars per RACC, a nonzero amount that warrants contextual evaluation within the total dietary pattern.

HEI-2015 total score improvements: baked beans vs. baked beans + canned beans

Table 2 presents HEI-2015 component score changes for protein food replacement, comparing baked beans alone (B) and baked beans + canned beans (BC). Table 4 presents total HEI-2015 score changes across all five replacement scenarios.

Table 2. HEI-2015 Total and Component Score Changes Following Isocaloric Replacement of Protein Foods with Baked Beans or Baked Beans + Canned Beans: Children 2–18 Years and Adults ≥19 Years, 1 Serving, NHANES 2001–2018

HEI-2015 Component
(Max Score)
Children 2–18y
Baked Beans Δ
Children 2–18y
Baked+Canned Δ
Adults ≥19y
Baked Beans Δ
Adults ≥19y
Baked+Canned Δ
Total Score (100)+5.52 (0.065)**+5.75 (0.066)**+4.52 (0.042)**+4.72 (0.042)**
Total Vegetables (5)+0.99 (0.012)**+0.98 (0.012)**+0.71 (0.0065)**+0.70 (0.0064)**
Greens & Beans (5)+2.75 (0.028)**+2.76 (0.028)**+2.47 (0.019)**+2.48 (0.019)**
Total Fruit (5)−0.001 (0.0001)**−0.001 (0.0001)**−0.002 (0.0002)**−0.002 (0.0002)**
Whole Fruit (5)−0.001 (0.0003)**−0.001 (0.0003)**−0.003 (0.0003)**−0.003 (0.0003)**
Whole Grains (10)−0.017 (0.0029)**−0.017 (0.0029)**−0.003 (0.0007)**−0.003 (0.0007)**
Dairy (10)−0.024 (0.0013)**−0.024 (0.0013)**−0.028 (0.0009)**−0.028 (0.0009)**
Total Protein Foods (5)+0.139 (0.0063)**+0.142 (0.0063)**+0.042 (0.0028)**+0.044 (0.0028)**
Seafood & Plant Protein (5)+2.175 (0.028)**+2.182 (0.028)**+1.811 (0.017)**+1.818 (0.017)**
Fatty Acids (10)−0.209 (0.0073)**−0.168 (0.0072)**−0.107 (0.0059)**−0.067 (0.0059)**
Sodium (10)−0.763 (0.015)**−0.643 (0.014)**−0.728 (0.0088)**−0.627 (0.0082)**
Refined Grains (10)+0.178 (0.0055)**+0.178 (0.0055)**+0.080 (0.0022)**+0.080 (0.0022)**
Saturated Fats (10)+0.781 (0.011)**+0.776 (0.011)**+0.681 (0.0064)**+0.676 (0.0063)**
Added Sugars (10)−0.478 (0.0057)**−0.416 (0.0050)**−0.405 (0.0037)**−0.350 (0.0033)**

Values are least squares mean deltas with standard errors in parentheses (SE = standard error). B = baked beans alone (130 g RACC); Baseline HEI-2015: children = 47.1; adults = 50.4. ** p<0.0001 vs. baseline. Positive delta values for moderation components (Sodium, Saturated Fats, Added Sugars, Refined Grains) indicate lower intake of the nutrient to limit (improvement). Negative values for moderation components indicate higher intake (worsening).

Baseline HEI-2015 total scores were 47.1 for children (2–18 years) and 50.4 for adults (≥19 years), reflecting dietary patterns substantially below optimal diet quality. All replacement scenarios produced statistically significant HEI-2015 total score improvements in both age groups (all p<0.0001). Protein food replacement with one serving of baked beans produced the largest HEI improvements: +5.52 points in children and +4.52 points in adults. Replacing all foods produced the greatest absolute HEI gains: +8.52 points in children and +6.40 points in adults. White potato, starchy food, and vegetable replacement scenarios each produced improvements of approximately +1.5–2.1 points across both age groups.

The baked beans + canned beans combination produced consistently superior HEI improvements across every scenario, age group, and serving level. The advantage was largest for protein foods and all foods (0.20–0.29 HEI points at one serving and 0.31–0.48 HEI points at two servings) and smaller for white potatoes, starchy foods, and vegetables (0.07–0.09 and 0.09–0.12 HEI points, respectively), driven primarily by improvements in the Sodium and Added Sugars components when lower-sodium, zero-added-sugar canned beans partially replaced higher-sodium, added-sugar-containing baked beans.

HEI-2015 component drivers

The Greens and Beans and Seafood and Plant Protein components were the dominant HEI drivers across all scenarios. In the protein food replacement scenario, Greens and Beans improved by +2.75 points (children) and +2.47 points (adults), and Seafood and Plant Protein improved by +2.18 and +1.81 points, respectively. These two components together accounted for approximately 90% of the total HEI improvement in the protein foods scenario, reflecting the reclassification of baked beans as both a legume (vegetable subgroup) and a plant protein source within the HEI-2015 scoring framework.

Three HEI components showed adverse changes with baked bean replacement. The Sodium component decreased (worsened) across all scenarios, most substantially for protein food replacement (−0.76 points in children, −0.73 in adults), reflecting the high sodium content of baked beans. The Added Sugars component also decreased (worsened) for baked beans alone (−0.48 points in children, −0.41 in adults for protein food replacement), reflecting the 1.62 tsp eq of added sugars per RACC of baked beans. The Fatty Acids component showed small adverse changes in most scenarios. Importantly, these decrements were substantially mitigated in the baked beans + canned beans combination: the Sodium component decrement was reduced by 0.10–0.12 points and the Added Sugars decrement by 0.05–0.06 points compared to baked beans alone.

Despite the Sodium and Added Sugars component decrements, total HEI-2015 improvements were positive and substantial in all scenarios, demonstrating that the nutrient density gains from Greens and Beans, Seafood and Plant Protein, Total Protein Foods, Total Vegetables, and the moderation components of Saturated Fats and Refined Grains more than compensated for the adverse sodium and added sugar contributions of baked beans.

Nutrient intakes

Table 3 presents key nutrient delta values for protein food replacement, the highest-impact scenario, at one and two serving levels for both replacement exposures. All values are statistically significant at p<0.0001.

Table 3. Key Nutrient Changes Following Isocaloric Replacement of Protein Foods with Baked Beans (Baked) or Baked Beans + Canned Beans (BC): Children 2–18 Years and Adults ≥19 Years, NHANES 2001–2018

NutrientChildren
Baked 1 srv
Children
BC 1 srv
Adults
Baked 1 srv
Adults BC 1 srvChildren
Baked 2 srv
Adults
Baked 2 srv
Potassium (mg)+162 (1.9)+162 (1.9)+161 (1.1)+161 (1.1)+252 (3.3)+274 (2.0)
Iron (mg)+1.44 (0.016)+1.40 (0.016)+1.45 (0.0084)+1.40 (0.0082)+2.23 (0.028)+2.47 (0.016)
Folate DFE (µg)+12 (0.21)+15 (0.23)+11 (0.17)+15 (0.18)+19 (0.33)+19 (0.29)
Calcium (mg)+35 (0.39)+34 (0.39)+35 (0.26)+34 (0.26)+53 (0.68)+59 (0.47)
Magnesium (mg)+22 (0.27)+22 (0.27)+21 (0.16)+21 (0.16)+34 (0.45)+36 (0.29)
Dietary Fiber (g)+4.5 (0.045)+4.7 (0.047)+4.7 (0.026)+4.9 (0.027)+7.0 (0.079)+8.1 (0.049)
Saturated Fat (g)−1.66 (0.019)−1.65 (0.019)−1.73 (0.012)−1.72 (0.012)−2.61 (0.032)−2.95 (0.021)
Cholesterol (mg)−43 (0.64)−44 (0.64)−51 (0.40)−52 (0.40)−69 (1.1)−89 (0.72)
Sodium (mg)+151 (2.5)+125 (2.3)+175 (1.7)+147 (1.6)+233 (4.2)+297 (3.1)
Added Sugars (tsp eq)+1.34 (0.013)+1.17 (0.012)+1.43 (0.0072)+1.25 (0.0063)+2.08 (0.023)+2.45 (0.014)
Total Sugars (g)+7.3 (0.072)+6.4 (0.064)+7.7 (0.040)+6.9 (0.036)+11.3 (0.13)+13.2 (0.079)
Protein (g)−3.6 (0.056)−3.5 (0.056)−4.7 (0.047)−4.6 (0.047)−5.5 (0.093)−7.9 (0.084)

Values are least squares mean deltas with standard errors in parentheses (SE = standard error). Baked = baked beans alone; BC = baked beans + canned beans combined. srv = serving (130 g RACC for baked beans; combination uses equivalent caloric portions of baked and canned beans). Green values indicate favorable changes in shortfall nutrients or nutrients to limit; red values indicate unfavorable changes. All p<0.0001. Added sugars are expressed in teaspoon equivalents (tsp eq; 1 tsp eq = 4.2 g).

Table 4. HEI-2015 Total Score Changes Across All Replacement Scenarios: Baked Beans (Baked) and Baked Beans + Canned Beans (BC), Children 2–18 Years and Adults ≥19 Years, NHANES 2001–2018

Replacement Food GroupChildren
Baked Δ
Children BC ΔAdults
Baked Δ
Adults BC ΔChildren
Baked 2srv
Adults Baked 2srv
Protein Foods+5.52 (0.065)**+5.75 (0.066)**+4.52 (0.042)**+4.72 (0.042)**+5.81 (0.071)**+4.76 (0.050)**
White Potatoes+1.85 (0.044)**+1.92 (0.046)**+1.55 (0.030)**+1.62 (0.031)**+1.77 (0.043)**+1.49 (0.031)**
Starchy Foods+1.89 (0.044)**+1.97 (0.045)**+1.60 (0.030)**+1.67 (0.031)**+1.81 (0.043)**+1.54 (0.031)**
Vegetables+2.07 (0.043)**+2.16 (0.044)**+1.72 (0.029)**+1.80 (0.030)**+2.02 (0.044)**+1.73 (0.033)**
All Foods+8.52 (0.046)**+8.81 (0.046)**+6.40 (0.044)**+6.64 (0.044)**+9.46 (0.056)**+7.04 (0.056)**

Values are least squares mean deltas with standard errors in parentheses (SE = standard error). Baked = baked beans alone (130 g RACC); BC = baked beans + canned beans. Baseline HEI-2015: children = 47.1; adults = 50.4. ** p<0.0001 vs. baseline for all values. Two-serving values shown for baked beans only; BC two-serving values are 0.31–0.48 points higher than Baked two-serving values for protein foods and all foods, and 0.09–0.12 points higher for white potatoes, starchy foods, and vegetables.

Baked bean replacement consistently and significantly increased intakes of six DGA-identified shortfall nutrients across both age groups. For protein food replacement at one serving, potassium increased by +162 mg in children and +161 mg in adults, representing approximately 6–7% of the daily Adequate Intake (AI) for potassium from a single dietary exchange. Iron increased by +1.44–1.45 mg, meaningful given that pediatric iron deficiency is a prevalent micronutrient deficiency in U.S. children. Calcium increased by +34–35 mg, magnesium by +21–22 mg, and folate DFE by +11–12 µg per serving. Dietary fiber increased by +4.5 g in children and +4.7 g in adults per serving, and by +7.0 g and +8.1 g, respectively, with two-serving replacement. Fiber gains were slightly greater with the baked beans + canned beans combination (+4.7 g in children and +4.9 g in adults), reflecting the higher fiber content of canned beans (7.5 vs. 5.7 g per RACC). Saturated fat declined by 1.66–1.73 g per serving with protein food replacement, and cholesterol declined by 43–51 mg, both nutritionally favorable changes consistent with replacing higher-fat animal protein sources with plant-based baked beans. The two-serving replacement increased these benefits approximately 1.5- to 1.7-fold (saturated fat −2.61 to −2.95 g; cholesterol −69 to −89 mg).

The primary nutritional trade-off of baked beans is sodium and added sugars. Baked bean replacement increased daily sodium by +151 mg in children and +175 mg in adults for protein food replacement at one serving, and daily added sugars increased by +1.34 tsp eq (approximately 5.6 g) in children and +1.43 tsp eq (approximately 6.0 g) in adults. These increases reflect the commercial sauce in which baked beans are prepared. The baked beans + canned beans combination partially attenuated these trade-offs: daily sodium increased by +125 mg (children) and +147 mg (adults), and daily added sugars by +1.17 tsp eq (children) and +1.25 tsp eq (adults), approximately 16–17% less sodium and 13% fewer added sugars than baked beans alone.

It is critical to contextualize the added sugar contribution of baked beans within total dietary patterns. One serving of baked beans contributes 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) of added sugars, approximately 14% of the 50 g daily limit for a 2,000 kcal dietary pattern. This contribution is modest when weighed against the simultaneous delivery of substantial amounts of dietary fiber, potassium, iron, magnesium, and plant protein within the same 130 g serving.

Discussion

In our previous work24, the isocaloric replacement of protein foods with 1 and 2 servings of canned beans daily to the US typical dietary pattern significantly improved shortfall nutrient intakes. Intake of dietary fiber increased by 30% (4.9g per day) and 51% (8.4g per day), with replacement of protein foods with 1 and 2 serving of canned beans, respectively, relative to the US typical dietary pattern. Similarly, isocaloric replacement of protein foods with 1 and 2 servings of canned beans daily to the US typical dietary pattern significantly increased total diet quality scores by approximately 12% and 15%, respectively, with the majority of the total score improvement stemming from higher scores in several HEI sub-components, including total vegetables, greens and beans, seafood and plant protein.24 The present analysis of NHANES 2001–2018, representing the largest and most comprehensive modeling study of baked bean substitution to date, demonstrates that isocaloric replacement of protein foods, white potatoes, starchy foods, vegetables, or all foods with baked beans significantly improves HEI-2015 diet quality scores and multiple shortfall nutrient intakes in U.S. children and adults. The current analysis demonstrates that baked beans are a net nutritional benefit to the US dietary pattern, directly addressing a persistent ambiguity in nutrition practice regarding baked beans' suitability within health-promoting diets. The concern that added sugar and sodium content in baked beans should be weighed against their nutritional benefits is legitimate and warrants acknowledgment, but the data presented in the present analysis make clear that this weighing process yields a strongly favorable nutrient intake and diet quality outcome for baked beans. In the protein food replacement scenario, HEI total scores improved by 4.5–5.5 points while simultaneously delivering meaningful daily increases in potassium, iron, calcium, magnesium, and dietary fiber, and reducing saturated fat by 1.7 g and cholesterol by 43–51 mg per serving. The added sugar contribution of 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) per serving, representing approximately 14% of the 50 g daily added sugar limit, is insufficient to counterbalance these substantial nutritional benefits.

This interpretation is consistent with published observational evidence. Papanikolaou and Fulgoni19 using NHANES 1999–2002 found that adults consuming baked beans had significantly lower systolic blood pressure than non-consumers, even in the presence of higher sodium intakes, representing a finding that aligns with the mechanistic evidence that dietary potassium from legumes counteracts sodium's pressor effects through increased urinary sodium excretion and direct vasodilatory mechanisms.15,29 The present analysis confirms that each serving of baked beans delivers +347.5 mg of potassium, which, when coupled with reduced saturated fat and low cholesterol (4.3 mg per serving), produces an overall cardiovascular nutrient profile that substantially improves upon the protein foods it displaces.

Protein food replacement produced the largest HEI improvements, a finding explained by the nutritional profile of the foods being displaced. Protein food consumption in the American diet tends to be dominated by higher fat animal foods, which can provide greater total cholesterol, saturated fat and sodium. Baked beans replace this profile with minimal cholesterol, lower saturated fat, and substantial plant protein, fiber, and micronutrient contribution. The HEI scoring framework captures this exchange directly through improvements in the Greens and Beans (+2.75 points) and Seafood and Plant Protein (+2.18 points) components, with additional contributions from Saturated Fats (+0.78 points, reflecting lower saturated fat), Total Protein Foods, and Total Vegetables components.

The finding that sodium and added sugars components worsened with baked bean replacement warrants further examination. The Sodium HEI component declined by 0.76 points in children and 0.73 points in adults with protein food replacement, reflecting a net sodium increase of +151–175 mg per serving. However, this must be contextualized, such that this sodium increase accompanies a potassium increase of +161–162 mg, producing a sodium-to-potassium ratio consideration that is more nuanced than the sodium change alone. The American Heart Association recommends increasing potassium-rich foods to help counteract sodium's blood pressure-raising effects,30 and the potassium-to-sodium ratio in baked beans themselves (347.5 mg: 488.3 mg) approaches 1:1.4, thus substantially more favorable than many processed protein foods. Low-sodium baked bean varieties, increasingly available commercially, would eliminate this trade-off entirely while preserving all other nutritional benefits.

The added sugar contribution of baked beans, while modest at 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) per serving, is the nutritional characteristic most likely to prompt clinician hesitation. This analysis provides the clearest quantitative basis for evaluating this concern in context. The 1.62 tsp eq (approximately 6.8 g) of added sugars per serving represents approximately 14% of the 50 g daily added sugar limit and must be weighed against simultaneous delivery of 5.7 g dietary fiber, 2.44 mg iron, 347.5 mg potassium, and 6.5 g protein. The health consequences of inadequate iron intake in children, including impaired cognitive development and anemia16 and of insufficient potassium and dietary fiber across the lifespan are substantially more consequential than the modest added sugar contribution of one serving of baked beans. Discouraging baked bean consumption on the basis of their added sugar content, without accounting for the nutritional benefits they displace, may represent a counterproductive application of dietary guidance.

The baked beans + canned beans combination consistently outperformed baked beans alone, with advantages concentrated in the Sodium (25-27 mg/serving net reduction) and Added Sugars (0.17–0.18 tsp eq/serving net reduction) parameters. The combination also provided higher folate (+3 µg/serving) and dietary fiber (+0.15 g/serving) due to canned beans' higher folate DFE (56.6 vs. 26.0 µg/RACC) and fiber (7.5 vs. 5.7 g/RACC) content. These advantages are mechanistically straightforward: canned beans have approximately half the sodium of baked beans and zero added sugars, so their inclusion moderates the adverse contributions of baked beans' sauce while preserving or enhancing the shortfall nutrient delivery. For clinical counseling, this suggests that recommending a mixed bean approach, thus incorporating both baked and canned beans, may be a practical way to optimize the nutritional benefit of bean consumption for patients with specific concerns about sodium or added sugar.

Similar to other observational analyses, the present study is inclusive of limitations. The dietary modeling approach assumes simple proportional isocaloric substitution and does not account for the behavioral complexity of real-world dietary change, including palatability preferences, food preparation habits, and cultural food patterns. Results apply only to habitual consumers of each replacement food group on their recall day and should not be extrapolated to the full population. The baked bean nutritional profile reflects population-weighted mean consumption across all commercially available baked bean food codes in NHANES, and individual product sodium and sugar content may vary substantially.

Conclusions

Baked beans are a nutrient-dense, affordable, and practically accessible food whose modest added sugar content (approximately 14% of the 50 g daily added sugar limit per serving) is substantially and consistently outweighed by their contributions to shortfall nutrient intakes and overall diet quality. This modeling analysis using NHANES 2001–2018 demonstrates that isocaloric substitution of baked beans for protein foods, white potatoes, starchy foods, vegetables, or all foods significantly improves HEI-2015 diet quality scores and increases intakes of potassium, iron, calcium, magnesium, and dietary fiber in U.S. children and adults, while reducing saturated fat and cholesterol. The combination of baked beans and canned beans provides modestly superior nutritional outcomes by reducing the net sodium and added sugar increments from baked beans alone.

Baked beans can be included in health-promoting dietary patterns for children and adults, and concerns about their added sugar and sodium content should be interpreted in the context of the substantial nutritional benefits they provide, not as justification for avoidance. Dietitians, physicians, and public health communicators should actively promote baked beans as a practical, evidence-based strategy for improving legume intake, closing shortfall nutrient gaps, and helping to support long-term cardiometabolic health in the U.S. population.

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethics approval/consents have been previously conducted via the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Research Ethics Review Board at the National Center for Health Statistics.
Consent for publication
Not Applicable
Availability of data and materials
Publicly available US datasets were analyzed in the present study and can be found here https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes. The NHANES datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on request.
Competing Interests
YP as President of Nutritional Strategies Inc. provides food, nutrition and regulatory affairs consulting services for numerous food and beverage companies and non-profit food associations and has collaborated with other researchers on NHANES analyses. JS is a Professor in the Department of Food Science and Nutrition, University of Minnesota and has current grants from Taiyo and Barilla in the area of dietary fiber, and also serves on the Scientific Advisory Boards for Tate and Lyle and Atkins Nutritionals and Sustainable Nutrition. YP and JS are active members of the Scientific Advisory Council for the Quality Carbohydrate Council in the United States.
Funding
This research was funded by Cannedbeans.org on behalf of Bush's Brothers & Company and the Coalition for the Advancement of Pulses.

References

  1. U.S. Department of Agriculture; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020–2025. 9th ed. U.S. Government Printing Office; 2020. https://www.dietaryguidelines.gov.
  2. Lichtenstein AH, Appel LJ, Vadiveloo M, et al. 2021 Dietary guidance to improve cardiovascular health: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2021;144(23):e472-e487. doi:10.1161/CIR.0000000000001031.
  3. Zargarzadeh N, Mousavi SM, Santos HO, Aune D, Hasani-Ranjbar S, Larijani B, Esmaillzadeh A. Legume consumption and risk of all-cause and cause-specific mortality: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of prospective studies. Adv Nutr. 2023;14(1):64-76. doi:10.1016/j.advnut.2022.10.009.
  4. Thorisdottir B, Arnesen EK, Bärebring L, et al. Legume consumption in adults and risk of cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Food Nutr Res. 2023;67 doi:10.29219/fnr.v67.9541.
  5. Ha V, Sievenpiper JL, de Souza RJ, et al. Effect of dietary pulse intake on established therapeutic lipid targets for cardiovascular risk reduction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. CMAJ. 2014;186(8):E252-E262. doi:10.1503/cmaj.131727.
  6. Jayalath VH, de Souza RJ, Sievenpiper JL, et al. Effect of dietary pulses on blood pressure: a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled feeding trials. Am J Hypertens. 2014;27(1):56-64. doi:10.1093/ajh/hpt165.
  7. Bazzano LA, He J, Ogden LG, et al. Legume consumption and risk of coronary heart disease in US men and women: NHANES I epidemiologic follow-up study. Arch Intern Med. 2001;161(21):2573-2578. doi:10.1001/archinte.161.21.2573.
  8. Bielefeld D, Grafenauer S, Rangan A. The effects of legume consumption on markers of glycaemic control in individuals with and without diabetes mellitus: a systematic literature review of randomised controlled trials. Nutrients. 2020;12(7):2123. doi:10.3390/nu12072123.
  9. Viguiliouk E, Blanco Mejia S, Kendall CWC, Sievenpiper JL. Can pulses play a role in improving cardiometabolic health? Evidence from systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2017;1392 (1):43-57. doi:10.1111/nyas.13312.
  10. Luhovyy BL, Mollard RC, Panahi S, Nunez MF, Cho F, Anderson GH. Canned navy bean consumption reduces metabolic risk factors associated with obesity. Can J Diet Pract Res. 2015;76(1):33-37. doi:10.3148/cjdpr-2014-030.
  11. Marventano S, Izquierdo Pulido M, Sánchez-González C, et al. Legume consumption and CVD risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Public Health Nutr. 2017;20(2):245-254. doi:10.1017/S1368980016002475.
  12. Sievenpiper JL, Kendall CWC, Esfahani A, et al. Effect of non-oil-seed pulses on glycaemic control: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled experimental trials in people with and without diabetes. Diabetologia. 2009;52(8):1479-1495. doi:10.1007/s00125-009-1395-7.
  13. Mitchell DC, Lawrence FR, Hartman TJ, Curran JM. Consumption of dry beans, peas, and lentils could improve diet quality in the US population. J Am Diet Assoc. 2009;109(5):909-913. doi:10.1016/j.jada.2009.02.029.
  14. Mudryj AN, Yu N, Aukema HM. Nutritional and health benefits of pulses. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2014;39(11):1197-1204. doi:10.1139/apnm-2013-0557.
  15. Bailey RL, Parker EA, Rhodes DG, et al. Estimating sodium and potassium intakes and their ratio in the American diet: data from the 2011–2012 NHANES. J Nutr. 2015;146(4):745-750. doi:10.3945/jn.115.221184.
  16. Bailey RL, West KP Jr, Black RE. The epidemiology of global micronutrient deficiencies. Ann Nutr Metab. 2015;66(suppl 2):22-33. doi:10.1159/000371618.
  17. Brauchla M, Fulgoni VL. Cost-effective options for increasing consumption of under-consumed food groups and nutrients in the USA. Public Health Nutr. 2022;25(3):710-716. doi:10.1017/S1368980021000537.
  18. Drewnowski A, Rehm CD. Vegetable cost metrics show that potatoes and beans provide most nutrients per penny. PLoS One. 2013;8(5):e63277. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0063277.
  19. Papanikolaou Y, Fulgoni VL. Bean consumption is associated with greater nutrient intake, reduced systolic blood pressure, lower body weight, and a smaller waist circumference in adults: results from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 1999–2002. J Am Coll Nutr. 2008;27(5):569-576. doi:10.1080/07315724.2008.10719740.
  20. Papanikolaou Y, Slavin J, Fulgoni VL. Adult dietary patterns with increased bean consumption are associated with greater overall shortfall nutrient intakes, lower added sugar, improved weight-related outcomes and better diet quality. Nutr J. 2024;23(1):36. doi:10.1186/s12937-024-00937-1.
  21. Papanikolaou Y, Slavin J, Papanikolaou S, Fulgoni VL. Adding more beans to the US typical dietary pattern can lead to greater intake of shortfall nutrients and a higher diet quality in younger and older adults. Maturitas. 2024;186:108012. doi:10.1016/j.maturitas.2024.108012.
  22. Rehm CD, Drewnowski A. Replacing American snacks with tree nuts increases consumption of key nutrients among US children and adults: results of an NHANES modeling study. Nutr J. 2017;16(1):17. doi:10.1186/s12937-017-0238-5.
  23. Reedy J, Krebs-Smith SM, Miller PE, Liese AD, Kahle LL, Park Y, Subar AF. Higher diet quality is associated with decreased risk of all-cause, cardiovascular disease, and cancer mortality among older adults. J Nutr. 2014;144(6):881-889. doi:10.3945/jn.113.189407.
  24. Papanikolaou Y, Papanikolaou A, Slavin J. Replacing protein foods for canned beans increases shortfall nutrient intakes and improves diet quality in adults. Med Res Arch. 2025;13(9):6993. doi:10.18103/mra.v13i9.6993.
  25. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; National Center for Health Statistics. NHANES—National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Accessed May 1, 2026. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/.
  26. Moshfegh AJ, Rhodes DG, Baer DJ, et al. The US Department of Agriculture Automated Multiple-Pass Method reduces bias in the collection of energy intakes. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008;88(2):324-332. doi:10.1093/ajcn/88.2.324.
  27. Bowman SA, Clemens JC, Shimizu M, Moshfegh AJ. Food Patterns Equivalents Database 2017–2018: Methodology and User Guide. Food Surveys Research Group, USDA ARS; 2020. Accessed June 7, 2026. https://www.ars.usda.gov/ARSUserFiles/80400530/pdf/fped/FPED_1718.pdf
  28. Krebs-Smith SM, Pannucci TE, Subar AF, et al. Update of the Healthy Eating Index: HEI-2015. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2018;118(9):1591-1602. doi:10.1016/j.jand.2018.05.021.
  29. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Dietary Reference Intakes for Sodium and Potassium. National Academies Press; 2019. Accessed June 22, 2026. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK538102/
  30. American Heart Association. How potassium can help prevent or treat high blood pressure. Accessed May 18, 2026. https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/high-blood-pressure/changes-you-can-make-to-manage-high-blood-pressure/how-potassium-can-help-control-high-blood-pressure.

Article information

Authors

How to cite

Papanikolaou, Y., Slavin, J., 2026. Isocaloric Replacement of Commonly Consumed Food Groups with Baked Beans Improves Diet Quality and Shortfall Nutrient Intakes in U.S. Children and Adults: A Modeling Study Using NHANES 2001–2018. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0494

Record

Journal
Medical Research Archives
Section
Research Articles
Published
31 October 2026
ISSN
2375-1924
Downloads
94

Copyright and licence

Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.