Key findings
- Three levelsinto which the framework organises polio risk: primary structural drivers, secondary mediators and amplifiers, and dependent epidemiological outcomes
- Four stepsAssess, Plan, Implement and Optimise, repeated as new surveillance, vaccination and community data arrive
- Persistenceof poliovirus transmission is the primary outcome to which the framework links its determinants
- Conceptualproposal grounded in theoretical synthesis; it requires local validation, calibration and operational testing before implementation
Abstract
Despite decades of eradication efforts, poliovirus transmission persists and may re-emerge in settings where biological, environmental, infrastructural, institutional and social vulnerabilities converge. This persistence reflects not only gaps in vaccination or surveillance, but also the interaction between structural conditions and the intrinsic biological strategies that support poliovirus survival, replication and silent circulation, including acid stability, immune-response modulation and IRES-dependent translation of uncapped RNA. We propose a hierarchical consilient framework within the One Health approach that organises established determinants according to causal depth: primary structural drivers, psychosocial and institutional mediators, surveillance signals and dependent epidemiological outcomes. By linking these interacting levels primarily to the persistence of poliovirus transmission, the model clarifies why interventions targeting isolated components may achieve only temporary control without modifying the wider causal system. The framework supports coordinated, context-specific combinations of vaccination, environmental surveillance, sanitation measures, risk communication and community engagement. As a conceptual proposal grounded in theoretical synthesis rather than empirical data analysis, it requires local validation, calibration and operational testing before implementation.
Introduction
Although poliomyelitis has been targeted for global eradication, persistent and re-emerging poliovirus transmission in vulnerable settings demonstrates that polio risk cannot be explained by virological factors alone. It is also shaped by ecological, infrastructural, social, institutional and behavioural conditions that determine whether vaccination systems function, surveillance detects cases early, and communities accept preventive interventions.
The One Health framework is particularly relevant because poliovirus circulation is closely linked to human populations, sanitation systems, water quality, mobility, urban density, health-service access and environmental monitoring. In settings affected by conflict, displacement, poverty or damaged infrastructure, these factors may converge to create conditions favourable to transmission.
Existing risk assessments tend to list determinants without organising them according to causal depth. Hierarchical approaches in epidemiology, first systematised by Victora and colleagues, have shown that failure to respect the hierarchical inter-relationships among determinants leads to underestimation of the effects of distal (structural) factors. Building on this tradition, the present article proposes a hierarchical consilient framework specifically tailored to poliovirus persistence. Its purpose is to organise heterogeneous determinants according to their causal position—primary structural drivers, secondary mediators and amplifiers, and dependent epidemiological outcomes—thereby clarifying not only where polio risk is high, but also why it forms and which interventions should be prioritised.
In this perspective, polio risk emerges when interrupted immunisation, weak surveillance, unsafe water and sanitation, overcrowding, population displacement, misinformation and institutional mistrust interact over time with the virus’s intrinsic biological strategies for survival and immune evasion. The proposed model treats these determinants as part of a layered causal system rather than as isolated variables. Consequently, polio preparedness is framed as both a vaccination challenge and a systems-resilience challenge that requires integrated surveillance, high immunisation coverage, strengthened sanitation, rapid response capacity and sustained community trust.
Theoretical Approach and Research Strategy
This article is a conceptual and theoretical contribution. It does not present original empirical data, statistical analyses or quantitative model fitting. Its research strategy consists of a structured synthesis and hierarchical reorganisation of established knowledge drawn from the polio eradication literature, One Health principles, environmental surveillance practice and the classical hierarchical approach to epidemiological analysis.
The method employed is consilient: determinants already documented in the literature are positioned according to their causal depth (structural drivers → psychosocial and institutional mediators → surveillance signals → epidemiological outcomes) and are explicitly linked to a primary measurable outcome—the persistence of poliovirus transmission. The resulting architecture is intended to serve as an interpretive and decision-support framework rather than as a predictive statistical model. Because the work is theoretical, no statistical methods, sampling procedures or data-analysis techniques are applicable; local validation and operational testing are identified as necessary next steps before any implementation.
This explicit statement of the theoretical nature of the study responds to the need for a clearly articulated research strategy even in the absence of empirical data collection.
Key Risks for Polio Emergence and Spread
The principal factors associated with poliovirus emergence and continued transmission may be summarised as follows:
- Low or interrupted vaccination coverage: gaps in routine immunisation, missed communities and delayed catch-up campaigns.1,4
- Weak surveillance capacity: delayed detection of acute flaccid paralysis, incomplete laboratory confirmation and limited environmental sampling.3,6
- Poor water, sanitation and hygiene conditions: unsafe water, damaged sewerage systems and faecal contamination that favour faecal–oral transmission.1,5
- Population displacement and mobility: movement across districts, borders, camps or informal settlements that can spread infection and complicate follow-up vaccination.1,3,4
- Overcrowding and informal urbanisation: dense living conditions that increase exposure risk and reduce the effectiveness of standard outreach approaches.1,4,5
- Fragile health systems and institutional fragility: limited workforce, disrupted services, insecurity and reduced community access for vaccination teams.1,3,4,6
- Vaccine hesitancy, misinformation and delayed response: mistrust, campaign fatigue and failure to act rapidly on early signals from wastewater or surveillance systems.1,3–5,7
Polio within the One Health and Epidemic Intelligence Framework
Polio as a systems-level public health risk
Poliomyelitis is transmitted primarily through the faecal–oral route and is therefore closely associated with sanitation, hygiene, water safety, population density and health-system performance. The persistence of poliovirus circulation in areas with low immunisation coverage demonstrates that vaccination, while central, must be embedded in broader systems of surveillance, infrastructure and community engagement.
Poliovirus risk also has a distinct virological dimension. Structural studies show that key receptor-binding regions can lie within capsid depressions known as canyons, shaping how antibodies access or compete with receptor-binding sites. As an enterovirus, poliovirus is stable at acidic pH, allowing orally acquired virus to survive gastrointestinal conditions and reach intestinal tissues. Intrahost evolution in poliovirus protein 2B has been associated with more effective suppression of host interferon responses in tissue-specific immune microenvironments. Beyond these features, the virus employs a distinctive translational strategy: the positive-strand RNA genome lacks the 5′ cap structure typical of eukaryotic mRNAs, yet is efficiently translated by host ribosomes through an internal ribosome entry site (IRES) located in the 5′ untranslated region. The single-stranded RNA folds into extensive secondary structures that recruit the cellular translation machinery, enabling rapid polyprotein production even under conditions of host translational shut-off. These mechanisms support efficient intracellular replication, silent spread and persistence, and are summarised in Table 1.
Table 1. Summary of poliovirus mechanisms supporting biological persistence and immune evasion and their relevance for risk assessment
| Mechanism | Biological function | Relevance for polio risk | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Canyon-mediated receptor binding | Receptor-binding regions positioned within capsid depressions can limit antibody access while preserving receptor interaction. | Helps explain how structure shapes immune recognition and neutralisation. | 9 |
| Acid stability during oral entry | Non-enveloped virion remains stable in acidic gastrointestinal conditions. | Supports survival after oral exposure and passage toward intestinal tissues. | 10 |
| Interferon-response suppression | Intrahost changes involving protein 2B may help overcome tissue-specific innate immune responses. | May contribute to persistence in different tissue microenvironments. | 11 |
| IRES-dependent translation of uncapped RNA | Positive-strand RNA lacks a 5′ cap yet is translated via an IRES whose secondary structures recruit host ribosomes. | Enables efficient polyprotein synthesis even under host translational shut-off, supporting silent spread and persistence. | 17 |
| Combined effect | Structural shielding, environmental stability, innate-response modulation and IRES-mediated translation interact. | Supports silent circulation, delayed immune clearance and a stronger rationale for integrated surveillance. | 9–11,17 |
A One Health perspective situates polio within the interaction between human health, environmental contamination, urban ecology, mobility and institutional capacity. Wastewater and environmental surveillance can reveal poliovirus circulation before paralytic cases are detected, linking environmental monitoring directly to human disease prevention.
Early warning, environmental surveillance and vaccination
For polio, epidemic intelligence depends on the integration of acute flaccid paralysis surveillance, laboratory confirmation, vaccination coverage data, population-movement information and environmental surveillance. These data streams support early detection of both wild poliovirus and circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus. Early warning is especially important in fragile and humanitarian settings, where conflict, displacement, damaged sanitation networks and disrupted health services can interrupt routine immunisation and delay outbreak response.
The effectiveness of early-warning systems depends on data quality, timeliness, laboratory capacity, field access and institutional response. Where vaccination records are incomplete, surveillance teams cannot reach communities, or mistrust limits participation, poliovirus circulation may remain undetected until preventable cases occur.
Digital tools and predictive modelling
Geographic information systems, mobility data, vaccination registries, environmental sampling and machine-learning tools can identify areas where polio risk is increasing. However, digital prediction becomes more useful when variables are organised causally rather than simply aggregated. A hierarchical model distinguishes upstream structural vulnerabilities from mediating social factors and downstream disease outcomes, making risk assessment more interpretable and actionable.
Fragile settings and trust
Fragile and conflict-affected settings represent critical environments for polio risk. Destroyed infrastructure, interrupted vaccination programmes, population displacement, overcrowding and weak surveillance may combine to create favourable conditions for transmission. Social and behavioural variables—vaccine confidence, trust in health authorities, misinformation, stigma and campaign fatigue—function as mediators and amplifiers: they may not create the original structural exposure, but they can accelerate or delay the transformation of vulnerability into persistent transmission.
Hierarchical Consilient Framework for Polio Risk Prediction
Rationale and aim
The proposed hierarchical consilient framework organises polio risk into three analytical levels: primary structural drivers, secondary mediators and amplifiers, and dependent epidemiological outcomes. It does not reduce transmission to a single cause. Instead, it supplies an interpretive architecture for understanding how immunisation gaps, sanitation failures, social vulnerability, institutional fragility and viral circulation interact over time.
The original contribution of the framework does not lie in the identification of previously unknown risk factors. It lies in the systematic positioning of established virological, environmental, infrastructural, institutional and psychosocial determinants according to their causal depth, and in the explicit linkage of their joint action to a primary measurable outcome—the persistence of poliovirus transmission. By clarifying why interventions that address only one level of the hierarchy often produce temporary gains without interrupting the underlying causal system, the model supports the selection of coordinated, context-specific interventions across all relevant layers. Persistent transmission, in turn, sustains the risk of re-emergence in vulnerable territories.
Primary structural drivers
Primary drivers are the structural conditions that create the possibility of poliovirus transmission. They include low or interrupted vaccination coverage, unsafe water and sanitation, overcrowding, population displacement, weak health infrastructure, limited laboratory capacity, fragile surveillance systems and restricted access to vulnerable communities. Ecological and systemic vulnerability can be interpreted through the progressive weakening of protective systems: immunisation programmes lose continuity, sanitation networks deteriorate, population movement increases, and health systems become less able to detect and contain transmission. This staged progression is summarised in Table 2.
Table 2. Conceptual framework for polio risk progression across systemic stages.
| Risk stage | Vaccination status | Water, sanitation & environment | Population & access | Likely outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low risk | High routine coverage; campaigns reach most children. | Safe water and functioning sanitation reduce faecal–oral exposure. | Stable population with reliable access to services. | Transmission risk controlled; routine prevention sufficient. |
| Emerging risk | Localised gaps in missed or mobile communities. | Sanitation stress or sewerage disruption increases exposure. | Movement or hard-to-reach groups complicate follow-up. | Silent circulation may begin before clinical cases. |
| High risk | Routine vaccination interrupted; campaign coverage uneven. | Unsafe water, faecal contamination and overcrowding favour spread. | Displacement or insecurity limits access for teams. | Outbreak probability rises; detection delayed. |
| Active transmission | Large susceptible pockets remain despite emergency activities. | Environmental contamination indicates ongoing circulation. | Mistrust, misinformation or conflict reduces response effectiveness. | Rapid outbreak response and intensified vaccination required. |
| Recovery & control | Catch-up and supplementary activities close immunity gaps. | Sanitation support and monitoring reduce transmission opportunities. | Community engagement improves access and acceptance. | Transmission chains interrupted; system returns to enhanced prevention. |
Secondary mediators, amplifiers and operational logic
Secondary mediators and amplifiers influence whether structural vulnerability becomes active polio transmission. They include vaccine hesitancy, misinformation, institutional mistrust, limited community engagement, stigma, collective stress, poor public communication, social inequality and delayed access to care. The operational logic of the framework can be summarised in four iterative steps: Assess polio-related vulnerabilities; Plan targeted vaccination and surveillance priorities; Implement prevention and response actions; Optimise the model through continuous updating of epidemiological, environmental and community-level data.
Figure 1 illustrates the Assess–Plan–Implement–Optimise cycle. Figure 2 presents the general hierarchical causal architecture linking structural drivers, mediators, analytical integration and public-health outputs, with persistence of transmission as the primary outcome of interest.
Epidemiological outcomes and analytical formalisation
Polio-related epidemiological outcomes are dependent variables resulting from the interaction between primary and secondary factors. They include silent poliovirus circulation, environmental detection of virus, acute flaccid paralysis cases, delayed diagnosis, delayed outbreak response, geographic spread and reduced effectiveness of vaccination campaigns. A formal risk model can be developed through causal diagrams, Bayesian networks, structural equation modelling or interpretable machine-learning pipelines that weight variables according to their position in the causal hierarchy. Such formalisation remains a task for future empirical work.
Operational Steps for Polio Preparedness
Step 1 – Assess. Identify structural risk through vaccination coverage, sanitation indicators, population movement, urban density, health-facility access, acute flaccid paralysis surveillance and environmental sampling.
Step 2 – Plan. Integrate mediating factors such as vaccine confidence, misinformation, institutional trust, community access and communication barriers to identify which vulnerabilities are most likely to interfere with vaccination and surveillance.
Step 3 – Implement. Translate assessment into action. Low-risk areas require routine maintenance; medium-risk areas require intensified environmental monitoring, catch-up vaccination and community engagement; high-risk areas require rapid vaccination campaigns, sanitation interventions, targeted communication and outbreak-response deployment.
Step 4 – Optimise. Use feedback from new surveillance results, vaccination data, community reports, wastewater monitoring and outbreak investigations to update risk estimates and recalibrate priorities. Together these steps allow preparedness to move from reactive outbreak control toward anticipatory prevention.
Practical Application: Post-Conflict Informal Urban Area
A post-conflict informal urban area provides a useful test case. Primary drivers may include destroyed water and sanitation networks, overcrowding, interrupted vaccination programmes, population displacement, limited health infrastructure and reduced laboratory or field surveillance capacity. Secondary factors may include mistrust in authorities, collective trauma, vaccine misinformation, campaign fatigue and low adherence to preventive measures. Their interaction increases the probability of silent circulation, delayed detection and uncontrolled transmission.
From risk factors to measurable variables
For algorithmic implementation, each risk factor should be translated into observable variables: vaccination coverage through routine and campaign data; sanitation vulnerability through access to safe water and sewerage indicators; surveillance strength through acute flaccid paralysis detection and laboratory timeliness; community trust through qualitative feedback, refusal rates or local engagement indicators. Within the proposed hierarchy these variables are not treated as equivalent components of an additive checklist. Structural drivers establish baseline vulnerability; psychosocial and institutional mediators may amplify or mitigate it; environmental and epidemiological surveillance provide signals of ongoing circulation. Their joint assessment is linked primarily to the persistence of poliovirus transmission.
Contribution to epidemic risk assessment
The model contributes by identifying the mechanisms through which vulnerability becomes transmission. A district with adequate sanitation but low vaccine acceptance requires a different response from one with high campaign acceptance but damaged water systems, weak surveillance and displaced populations.
Discussion
The persistence of poliovirus transmission despite long-standing eradication programmes indicates that listing individual risk factors is insufficient when these factors are addressed in isolation. The main contribution of the hierarchical consilient framework is to organise established determinants by causal depth and operational relevance, thereby clarifying how structural conditions, psychosocial and institutional mediators, and surveillance capacity jointly sustain transmission. Importantly, these higher-level drivers interact with the virus’s intrinsic biological strategies—including canyon-mediated receptor binding, acid stability, interferon suppression and IRES-dependent translation of uncapped RNA—that enable efficient replication, immune evasion and silent circulation even when host defences are only partially compromised. Rather than treating all risk factors as equivalent items on a checklist, the model links their interaction primarily to persistence and, consequently, to the risk of re-emergence.
The framework builds directly on the hierarchical conceptual approach introduced by Victora et al. for epidemiological analysis. That classic work demonstrated that distal determinants are systematically underestimated when analytical models fail to respect causal hierarchy. The present contribution adapts and extends this logic to the specific problem of poliovirus persistence within a One Health setting, incorporating both structural/social layers and the virus’s own biological persistence mechanisms.
Operationally, the framework is intended to complement—not replace—existing polio surveillance and immunisation systems. It adds a causal layer to current data platforms, helping decision-makers understand why particular settings require intensified vaccination, environmental sampling, risk communication or sanitation support. The approach is especially relevant in fragile and conflict-affected contexts, where polio risk arises from the simultaneous presence of multiple vulnerabilities. In such settings, hierarchical classification can guide prioritisation among vaccination campaigns, water and sanitation measures, surveillance reinforcement, public communication and community engagement.
Limitations and conditions for applicability
The model depends on reliable, timely and comparable data. In fragile contexts, data collection is frequently incomplete, community access may be restricted, and environmental surveillance can be difficult to sustain. The framework should therefore be regarded as adaptable and progressive; it requires local validation and calibration before operational use. Psychosocial mediators such as trust and vaccine confidence are often measured with lower precision than vaccination coverage or wastewater signals; over-interpretation of these variables should be avoided. Because the present work is purely conceptual, no quantitative validation or performance metrics are available; these constitute essential next steps.
Future development
Future work should focus on the construction of a prototype that integrates vaccination coverage, acute flaccid paralysis surveillance, environmental poliovirus monitoring, infrastructure indicators, population-movement data and community-level information. Pilot studies in high-risk urban areas and crisis-affected territories would allow the model to be tested, refined and eventually formalised through causal diagrams or interpretable predictive tools. Collaboration with national polio programmes and the Global Polio Eradication Initiative would facilitate operational relevance and uptake.
Conclusion
Persistent poliovirus transmission cannot be attributed to any single unresolved determinant. It results from the convergence of multiple vulnerabilities operating at different causal levels: immunisation gaps create biological susceptibility that the virus can rapidly exploit through efficient IRES-mediated translation and other immune-evasion strategies; damaged water and sanitation systems increase exposure; displacement and insecurity hinder service delivery; weak surveillance delays detection; and mistrust or misinformation reduce participation in vaccination campaigns. When these factors are addressed separately, interventions may achieve temporary control without modifying the causal system that sustains transmission.
A hierarchical consilient approach organises these determinants according to their causal depth and links their interaction primarily to the persistence of poliovirus transmission. By supporting coordinated, context-specific combinations of vaccination, environmental surveillance, sanitation measures and community engagement, the framework may contribute to more durable interruption of transmission and thereby reduce the risk of re-emergence. As a conceptual model grounded in theoretical synthesis, however, it requires local validation, calibration and operational testing before any implementation.
Declarations
- Funding
- This research received no external funding.
- Institutional review board statement
- Not applicable (theoretical conceptual work).
- Informed consent statement
- Not applicable.
- Data availability statement
- All data relevant to this study are contained within the article. Further information may be requested from the corresponding author.
- Conflicts of interest
- The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- World Health Organization. Poliomyelitis. April 2, 2025. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/poliomyelitis
- World Health Organization. Polio eradication strategy 2022–2026: Delivering on a promise, extension to 2029. 2025. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240109506
- World Health Organization. Global polio surveillance action plan 2025–2026. 2025. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://polioeradication.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Global-Polio-Surveillance-Action-Plan-2025-2026.pdf
- Global Polio Eradication Initiative. Polio tools, protocols and guidelines. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://polioeradication.org/tools/gpei-tools-protocols-and-guidelines/
- UK Health Security Agency. Environmental surveillance for polio. July 7, 2026. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/polio-global-eradication-nac-and-environmental-surveillance/environmental-surveillance-for-polio
- Lopez AS, Oberste MS, Kidd S. Chapter 12: Poliomyelitis. In: Manual for the Surveillance of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2024. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://www.cdc.gov/surv-manual/php/table-of-contents/chapter-12-poliomyelitis.html
- Global Polio Eradication Initiative. Variant poliovirus (cVDPV): Causes, risks and prevention. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://polioeradication.org/about-polio/the-virus/vaccine-derived-polioviruses/
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, United Nations Environment Programme, World Health Organization, World Organisation for Animal Health. One Health joint plan of action 2022–2026: Working together for the health of humans, animals, plants and the environment. World Health Organization; 2022. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240059139
- Charnesky AJ, Faust JE, Lee H, et al. A human monoclonal antibody binds within the poliovirus receptor-binding site to neutralize all three serotypes. Nat Commun. 2023;14:6335. doi:10.1038/s41467-023-41052-9
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Clinical overview of poliomyelitis. May 9, 2024. Accessed September 11, 2026. https://www.cdc.gov/polio/hcp/clinical-overview/index.html
- Xiao Y, Dolan PT, Goldstein EF, et al. Poliovirus intrahost evolution is required to overcome tissue-specific innate immune responses. Nat Commun. 2017;8:375. doi:10.1038/s41467-017-00354-5
- Namageyo-Funa A, Greene SA, Henderson E, et al. Update on vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreaks—Worldwide, January 2023–June 2024. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2024;73(41):909-916. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm7341a1
- Mercer LD, Safdar RM, Ahmed J, et al. Spatial model for risk prediction and sub-national prioritization to aid poliovirus eradication in Pakistan. BMC Med. 2017;15:180. doi:10.1186/s12916-017-0941-2
- Habib MA, Soofi S, Cousens S, et al. Community engagement and integrated health and polio immunisation campaigns in conflict-affected areas of Pakistan: a cluster randomised controlled trial. Lancet Glob Health. 2017;5(6):e593-e603. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30184-5
- Agrawal P, Neel A, Deresse AS, Gerber S, Alonge O. Facilitators and barriers to community engagement in the Global Polio Eradication Initiative—A mixed methods study. PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023;3(4):e0001643. doi:10.1371/journal.pgph.0001643
- Victora CG, Huttly SR, Fuchs SC, Olinto MTA. The role of conceptual frameworks in epidemiological analysis: a hierarchical approach. Int J Epidemiol. 1997;26(1):224-227. doi:10.1093/ije/26.1.224
- Willey JM, Sherwood LM, Woolverton CJ. Prescott’s Microbiology. 10th ed. McGraw-Hill Education; 2017.
Article information
Authors
- Giovanni MeledandriHuman Science Department, Guglielmo Marconi University, Rome (RM) 00193, ItalyCorresponding author · [email protected]
- Eva Maria AretiniHuman Science Department, Guglielmo Marconi University, Rome (RM) 00193, Italy
How to cite
Meledandri, G., Aretini, E. M., 2026. Persistent Poliovirus Transmission: A Hierarchical Consilient Framework within the One Health Approach. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0676
Record
- Journal
- Medical Research Archives
- Issue
- Vol 14 No 10 (2026)
- Section
- Research Articles
- Published
- 31 October 2026
- ISSN
- 2375-1924
- Downloads
- 69
Copyright and licence
Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.