Abstract

The debate in the United States over policy toward COVID-19 raised broader questions about vaccination policy in general. The dominant national policy is one of exceptionally far-reaching vaccination mandates, under legislation exempting vaccine manufacturers from product-liability. Critics of this policy, being censored by corporate media and social platforms, resorted to right-wing venues to reach a mass audience. In so doing, they aligned themselves with interests that oppose environmental regulation and free universal healthcare. Political demands that in substance are complementary were thus placed in opposition to one another. This essay challenges that outcome by reviewing the specific arguments put forward by the critics. It concludes by suggesting that a proper understanding of their position would make possible a realignment of political forces that would in turn enable policies conducive to improved public health.

Introduction

The experience of COVID-19 generated a political conflict, particularly pronounced in the United States, in which criticism of the privately owned pharmaceutical industry is oddly aligned with opposition to progressive policies on the environment and on access to healthcare. This essay explores the basis on which that alignment could be challenged. Big pharma’s interest in selling its products at all costs (including via mandated vaccination) cannot be effectively counteracted unless the underlying conditions of public health are addressed. This would require an agenda of environmental protection, elimination of poverty, and free universal healthcare. If those who now challenge big pharma could be persuaded to recognize this observation, the political deadlock that has blocked necessary public awareness would be lifted and the prospects for sounder policies on all issues affecting public health greatly improved.

Political complexity of the COVID-19 debate

Politics in the United States is gripped by an alliance that is at once paradoxical and paralyzing. It binds together, in a bizarre marriage of convenience, demands that clash frontally with one another. The most radical challengers to the capitalist pharmaco-medical complex – to its actual practices – have cast their lot with an administration that not only opposes free universal healthcare but also seeks to increase reliance on fossil fuels and to erase all checks on industrial pollution. Some of the most dedicated defenders of individual bodily autonomy from governmental mandates have thrown their support to a president who calls for a national ban on abortion.1 And some of the most persistent critics of Pentagon-supported “gain of function” research (aimed at making pathogens more deadly) are more eager to denounce China’s role in advancing it than the US role in initiating it,2 thereby feeding into official US anti-China rhetoric – a key component to the ongoing US agenda of global military supremacy.

This strange alliance is facilitated – typically, on the basis of little if any familiarity with the issues – by many who consider themselves progressive (including even some who identify as socialists) insofar as they favor free universal healthcare, seek to safeguard the natural environment, insist on reproductive freedom, and strive for a world at peace. However, these same progressive sectors and individuals belie their own values to the extent that they endorse the censorship of reports and research that call into question prevailing medical orthodoxy, particularly as to the alleged public health benefits of a system that glosses over the underlying causes of much illness (environmental, economic, nutritional and psychological) while suppressing news of adverse health-effects of its own practices (most especially, its vaccination mandates).3

Holding a progressive or anti-capitalist political position in no way necessarily implies ratifying such censorship (or in some cases not even noticing that censorship is taking place4). It is precisely this suppression of disturbing evidence – and of alternative therapies – that, by marginalizing medical dissidents, has driven many of the latter to articulate their views in right-wing venues. Ironically, “progressives” then use this very fact of right-wing platforming to bolster their contention that disclosures challenging the dominant medical consensus are politically inspired, associated with an objectionable agenda, and therefore groundless.5 In so doing, they overlook or forget the eminently political trajectory of the approach they support, which has given the US the lowest-ranking public health outcomes among high-income countries (as measured by life-expectancy and infant mortality), alongside the world’s highest per capita health-related expenses, highest incidence of obesity, and highest levels of compulsory inoculation.

The distinctive history driving these outcomes is that of the most unbridled capitalism. While in other high-income countries capital has had to accommodate varying degrees of restraint imposed by working-class political parties, in the US it has been able, except for short periods and within certain regional and local spaces, to fully set the parameters of public policy. In the sphere of health policy, this has led to an unmatched level of hegemony exercised by the privately owned pharmaceutical industry. Big pharma in the US plays a crucial role in guiding medical education and research. It provides the bulk of funding to the American Academy of Pediatrics, which effectively determines the country’s childhood vaccination protocols.6 It sponsors and therefore, to a unique degree, sets the limits to what can be covered in major TV news-programs. And it constitutes the most ubiquitous presence in financing and lobbying legislators. In a country that relies more on litigation than on regulation to protect the public from economic actors’ malfeasance, big pharma consequently enjoys blanket immunity – thanks to a federal law passed in 1986 – from lawsuits over vaccine injuries.

This whole configuration of power has been brought into the spotlight through debates unleashed by COVID-19 and the response to it. The public health bureaucracy, thoroughly permeated by big pharma, used putatively progressive rhetoric of “social responsibility” to promote acceptance of government-imposed vaccination mandates, despite unproven assumptions as to their medical justification (hence, “emergency use authorization”). Many healthcare professionals who objected to those mandates felt drawn into taking a stance which, professing anti-authoritarianism, embraced the rabidly repressive and science-denying forces represented by Donald Trump. Their pretense of thereby acting on a commitment to free-speech principles gained unmerited plausibility from the censorship that the whole “liberal” corporate-media complex (including platforms like Facebook, YouTube, and Wikipedia) imposed on the reporting and discussion of vaccination injuries.7 Republican politicians who supported erasing evidence of climate-change from official reports – not to mention whitewashing the history of US slavery – thus suddenly got the chance to present themselves as defenders of open scientific debate.

Radical implications of the critique of big pharma

As the COVID-19 emergency recedes, evidence clarifying the positions it brought out has increasingly come to the surface. Thanks (ironically) to Republican control over the US Senate, hearings chaired in 2025-26 by Senator Ron Johnson have made it possible to give broad exposure to data and analysis on vaccine injuries that had previously been kept out of public view.8 Among the expert witnesses at these hearings, attorney Aaron Siri and political economist Toby Rogers offered testimony particularly pertinent to our task of disentangling the political alignments around healthcare.

Aaron Siri’s legal work had given him the opportunity (in 2017) to conduct a formal deposition of top vaccinologist Dr. Stanley Plotkin, revealing the flimsy basis for Plotkin’s assertions about vaccine safety.9 Siri’s written testimony to the Johnson committee includes an exhaustive account of the unsuccessful search made by vaccinologists for studies that would disprove the role of multiple vaccinations – especially during infancy – in bringing on autism.10 The denial of any such link has remained an article of faith for many, despite parallel exponential increases, since 1986, in the levels of childhood vaccinations and of autism (let alone the temporal convergence between the two that has been observed by parents of stricken children).11 Siri’s spoken testimony to the committee includes explaining how the CDC’s follow-up study (“V-safe assessment”) of the Covid shots – mandated under the 1986 law and based on a survey of 9.9 million volunteers who received the shots – was skewed to minimize the apparent toll taken by the shots by (1) not including check-boxes for their more serious possible effects, such as chest-pains, and (2) withholding responses for impacts reported more than 7 days after the shot (until forced by litigation to disclose them).12 The study nonetheless showed 1.87 percent of respondents reporting a post-injection decline in their health, with severe episodes in half of those cases.13

Toby Rogers’ doctorate (from the University of Sydney) was based on a dissertation entitled “The Political Economy of Autism.”14 This work aptly – and rather exceptionally – ties the critique of hegemonic medical protocols to a radical political critique. Key chapters are entitled “Capitalist Conquest of Science and Medicine” (ch. 5) and “Political Economy of the Regulation of Vaccines” (ch. 9). Chapter 5 includes data from the year 2000 showing that the profit rate for big pharma was four times the average profit rate for Fortune 500 companies; it also presents copious data on big pharma’s decisive role in financing medical publications. Chapter 9 exposes, among other things, pervasive conflicts of interest in the CDC (Centers for Disease Control & Prevention) and the ACIP (Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices). Overall, the dissertation pioneers an approach that, by virtue of its consistent if cautiously articulated anti-capitalism, will need to be more widely applied if current adverse trends in public health are to be reversed. Rogers gives significant credit for this understanding on his part to Dr. Vicente Navarro, author of the popular Marxist exposé Dangerous to Your Health: Capitalism in Healthcare (Monthly Review Press, 1993). But the piece by Navarro that Rogers singles out is a short essay in the European Journal of Public Health entitled “Politics and health: a neglected area of research.”15

Both Aaron Siri and Toby Rogers illustrate the sense in which the debate over COVID-19 policy leads directly to systemic questions – initially about public health but, by extension, about the whole system of power in the United States. The reported adverse effects of the COVID shots exceeded by orders of magnitude those of previous inoculations.16 The hegemonic drive to block recognition of those effects highlighted the longstanding practice of suppressing critical discussion about any vaccine. This suppression had focused heavily on the vaccine/autism link because it was the incidence of autism that showed the most spectacular increase following passage of the 1986 law that protected vaccine-producers. But autism was not the only issue.

More generally at issue was the larger question of whether over-reliance on inoculation against particular diseases might have the seemingly paradoxical effect of weakening the body’s resistance to a wider range of disorders. The paradox is only apparent, however, because in fact the impact is all too straightforward, in that the injected substance disrupts the body’s natural immune responses, resulting in the well-known phenomena of (1) vaccination providing weaker protection than prior infection and (2) the steady weakening of injection-based immunity over time, generating a continuous “need” for boosters.17 The proliferation of boosters, in the case of COVID-19 injections, multiplied any initial damaging impact of the shots, and moreover, as found in a Cleveland Clinic study, increased the likelihood of subsequent infection.18 In addition, the boosters were observed to trigger the rapid onset and metastasis of cancers (affecting younger populations than before) as well as the sudden reactivation of cancers that had been in remission for years.19

The known or suspected side-effects of these as well as other inoculations point to the need for comprehensive studies comparing the general health of vaccinated and unvaccinated populations. Vaccination-advocates have steered clear of such studies, perhaps because they already have sufficient power to assure compliance with their regimen. The data recorded by dissident doctors like Paul Thomas point to superior general health in the unvaccinated,20 but these findings have remained marginalized. This gives all the more importance to the Dearborn (Michigan) data presented in Del Bigtree’s 2025 documentary film, An Inconvenient Study, based on the multi-year records of thousands of patients and showing levels of chronic illness approximately four times higher in the vaccinated than in the unvaccinated.21

Critique confronts censorship

The conflict over COVID-19 illustrates, in a particularly dramatic way, how the broader system of power in the US, despite its democratic trappings, operates to block policies that are needed – and on some issues consciously favored – by the popular majority. A consistent approach to public health would link the critique of pharmaco-medical impositions to a critique of the social causes of illness, in the tradition embodied by Vicente Navarro (and one might add Richard Levins22). As we have seen, however, what the US political process has accomplished (in effect) has been to assign critique of the professional orthodoxy and critique of the social causes of illness to two separate and opposed political forces. Each critique is thereby denied a role in forging the kind of unified political response that it would need in order to be effectively implemented. The only beneficiaries are then the financial interests that stand to profit in all spheres of policy.

Critics of medical orthodoxy have aptly noted the financial interests that drive the dominant approach but have not followed up by addressing the larger context of public health. This would require tackling the full range of interrelated factors that contribute to increasing levels of chronic illness.

The most all-encompassing of these factors is devastation of the natural environment. In an immediate sense, this means damage to the air we breathe and the water we drink. But it also refers to shrinking agricultural space, declining quality of soil, depleted aquifers and consequent debasement and squeezing of the food supply. Drought and flooding, aggravated by climate change, undermine the general conditions for food production. More specifically, the quality of food is affected by capitalist agriculture’s pervasive use of herbicides, pesticides, growth hormones, and genetic engineering.23 In addition, between the stages of cultivation and consumption, a significant portion of commercially distributed food undergoes the whole intermediate stage of processing, which entails introducing substances aimed at enhancing appearance and/or prolonging shelf-life and making consumption addictive.

The declining quality of food and the rising costs of its production aggravate the most pervasive factor in the ill health of large numbers of people, namely poverty.24 Poverty arises from the convergence of high prices, low wages, and inadequate social services, including transportation, education, welfare-assistance, and healthcare. Its adverse health effects are magnified by the resulting stress and often also by efforts to escape a harsh reality via substance abuse. Street crime and the dire conditions inflicted on prisoners and their families also come into play. All this is of course widely known but is generally sidestepped in debates over public health. Just as the pharma-driven media seek to discredit recognition of the scale of vaccination-injuries, so also, from the other direction, right-wing supporters of “medical freedom” consistently oppose policies that would curb environmental devastation and reduce – let alone eliminate – the burden of poverty.

Opposition to an anti-poverty agenda is hard-wired into the ruling-class consensus; it extends to Democrats as well as Republicans. By contrast, among those who prioritize public health and environmental protection, space exists for reasoned discussion about alternative approaches. Out of such discussion could emerge a majoritarian political force with real potential for setting policy. The big obstacle to arriving at the requisite transformative consensus is inadequate information and analysis. In the debate over COVID-19 – and over vaccination more broadly – the scope for discussion among progressives has been limited by a level of censorship so extreme that proponents of unlimited vaccination can easily feel no need to even look at evidence of vaccine-injuries.25 And in the evaluation of research studies, the possibility that such studies might induce “vaccine hesitancy” is viewed as sufficient grounds for rejecting – or at least offsetting with a disclaimer – even the most rigorously documented and duly qualified findings.

The thoroughness of the blackout shows up not only in exclusion from social platforms, but also in the widespread practice of forcing the retraction of research studies.26 Apparently, it is not enough to point out possible gaps or errors in an article; the article must be removed altogether from circulation. The rationale for so drastic a step is that it is necessary for the sake of protecting patients against potential harm. But this simply assumes what those seeking to bury the article should be expected to prove. Forced retraction is a poor substitute for scientific refutation. The now-classic case in the vaccine debates is that of Dr. Andrew Wakefield, who was ostracized from medical practice in the 1990s (in the US as well as in his native Britain) for daring to suggest even the possibility, meriting investigation, of a link between MMR vaccination and autism27 – an issue whose resonance has only grown in subsequent years.

Censorship at this level is ultimately targeting a whole sphere of lived experience: in this case, the observations – not to mention the shock – of those parents who see their recently vaccinated children abruptly plunged into a shutdown of their communicative and expressive faculties. Denialism is no less striking, however, in relation to the environmental impact of capitalist economic expansion. The only difference here is that it’s impossible for most people not to recognize the extent of climate disruption, so the response of policymakers, instead of trying to argue that the droughts, floods and super-storms are not occurring, is to simply ignore them. Within the currently prevailing rhetoric, concern for environmental devastation can then be simply mocked – along with feminism, anti-racism, etc. – as just one more expression of “wokeism.” Sadly, the disdain emitted by medical conformists toward the vaccine-injured, although coming from the opposite political direction, is not only just as callous but also just as ill-founded.

Conclusion

The exposure of environmental breakdown has been extensive and is continuously amplified by new catastrophes (the most recent being, at the time of this writing, the mudslides in Nepal from melting in the Himalayas28), but the policy impact is offset by the enormous influence of the fossil fuel sector, with its big tech allies and the government that serves them. Might there be greater scope for purposeful debate among healthcare professionals? That will depend on the extent to which reports and analyses that have previously been marginalized by censorship can be foregrounded, given wide publicity, and no longer seen as shackled to a right-wing agenda. Should this be achieved, a comprehensive alternative to current harmful practices – which damage alike the eco-system and the individual human body – will finally become a real political option.

References

  1. See Wallis, Victor. Covid-19 in the History of Capitalism. Capitalism Nature Socialism, 36:1 (2025), https://doi.org/10.1080/10455752.2024.2434559 and sources cited therein.
  2. For example, Breggin, Peter R., and Ginger Ross Breggin. COVID-19 and the Global Predators: We Are the Prey. Ithaca, NY: Lake Edge Press, 2021.
  3. Wallis, Victor. The Impact of Censorship on Covid-19 Policy Formation in the United States. Medical Research Archives, 11:4 (2023). doi.org/10.18103/mra.v11i4.3822 (updated with expanded references in Socialism and Democracy, 38:2/3 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1080/08854300.2024.2309805).
  4. An example is where Radhika Desai, while forcefully criticizing the capitalist response to Covid (Desai, Radhika. Capitalism, Coronavirus and War: A Geopolitical Economy. London: Routledge, 2023), links cases of poor national performance, in passing, to “lower vaccine access” (13). More proactively dismissive of pertinent evidence is the systematic exclusion of vaccination-critics from among the health-issue experts interviewed on the progressive podcast Democracy Now!.
  5. Based on the author’s experience debating these issues.
  6. American Academy of Pediatrics. Corporate and Organizational Supporters. https://www.aap.org/en/ways-to-give/current-corporate-and-organizational-supporters/
  7. For an overview of the censorship, see Brownstone Institute. The COVID Response at Five Years: A History of the End of Civilization. Austin, TX: Brownstone Inst., 2025, 36-54. For an extensive review of suppressed evidence on the origins of COVID-19, see Elijah, Sonia. 3/11 Viral Takeover. Elijah Light Press, 2026, esp. 24-46.
  8. US Senate. Committee on Homeland Security & Government Affairs. How the Corruption of Science Has Impacted Public Perception and Policies Regarding Vaccines. 9 Sept. 2025. https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/subcommittees/investigations/hearings/how-the-corruption-of-science-has-impacted-public-perception-and-policies-regarding-vaccines/
  9. Siri, Aaron. Vaccines, Amen: The Religion of Vaccines. Injecting Freedom, LLC, 2025, 9-30.
  10. Siri, Aaron. Testimony before US Senate Committee on Homeland Security & Government Affairs (19 May 2025). https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/Siri-Testimony.pdf
  11. See Olmsted, Dan, and Mark Blaxill. Denial: How Refusing to Face the Facts about Our Autism Epidemic Hurts Children, Families, and Our Future. New York: Skyhorse, 2017.
  12. US Senate hearing of 9 Sept. 2025 (note 8), at 2h33min.
  13. Hulscher, Nicolas, MPH. CDC V-Safe Data Reveals 185,285 People Reported Long-Term Health Problems After COVID-19 “Vaccination.” Focal Points. https://www.thefocalpoints.com/p/breaking-cdc-v-safe-data-reveals (This is many times the number that had traditionally sufficed to compel withdrawal of a product from the market.)
  14. Rogers, Toby. The Political Economy of Autism. PhD diss. University of Sydney (Australia), 2019. https://ses.library.usyd.edu.au/bitstream/handle/2123/20198/Rogers_T_thesis.pdf
  15. European Journal of Public Health, 18:4 (2008). https://academic.oup.com/eurpub/article/18/4/354/477874. Rogers notes Navarro’s influence on him on p. 349f of his dissertation.
  16. Reported deaths per year (source: the CDC’s Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System, VAERS) from COVID shots (8,156, of which 23.9% were within the first 2 days following the shot) vs. flu shots (76), in Table shown at US Senate hearing (note 8), at 2h24min. (Underreporting to VAERS is estimated to be by a factor of 31. Rose, Jessica, PhD. Safety Signals from [VAERS]. In Bridle, Byram, and Harvey Risch, MD et al. TOXIC SHOT: Facing the Dangers of the COVID “Vaccines.” Distr. by Amazon. [2024], 118.)
  17. See Thomas, Paul, MD (pediatrician), and DeeDee Hoover (“Just a Mom”). VAX FACTS: What to Consider Before Vaccinating at All Ages & All Stages of Life. New York: Morgan James Publishing, 2025, 49-57.
  18. Thomas and Hoover, VAX FACTS, p. 52f. See also Bridle, Byram W., PhD. Immunological Harms of the modRNA “Vaccines.” In: Bridle and Risch, TOXIC SHOT, 130-141.
  19. See Dalgleish, Angus, MD (oncologist). The connection between mRNA COVID vaccines and cancer relapse and occurrence (https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/Dalgleish-Testimony.pdf) and his spoken testimony (3 June 2026) to the US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. Plausible Mechanisms of COVID-19 Injections Causing Cancer and Attacks on Scientific Publications and Research (https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/subcommittees/investigations/hearings/plausible-mechanisms-of-covid-19-injections-causing-cancer-and-attacks-on-scientific-publications/), at mins. 38-43.
  20. Thomas and Hoover, VAX FACTS, 233-249.
  21. 80-minute documentary, freely accessible at https://www.aninconvenientstudy.com/. Reviewed, along with Siri’s Vaccines, Amen, in Wallis, Victor. Sharpening the Critique of Vaccination Mandates: A Review Essay. British Journal of Healthcare and Medical Research, 13:1 (2026). https://doi.org/10.14738/bjhr.1301.19799
  22. See Levins, Richard. Is capitalism a disease? In: Lewontin, Richard, and Richard Levins. Biology under the Influence: Dialectical Essays on Ecology, Agriculture, and Health. New York: Monthly Review Press, 2007, 297-320. Available at: https://monthlyreview.org/2000/09/01/is-capitalism-a-disease/
  23. See Bittman, Mark. Animal, Vegetable, Junk: A History of Food, from Sustainable to Suicidal. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2021.
  24. See Navarro, Vicente, MD. Medicine Under Capitalism. New York: Neale Watson Academic Publications, 1976.
  25. See Wallis, Victor. COVID-19 and Capitalism: The Shunning of Evidence in Sam Friedman’s “House Organ.” Capitalism Nature Socialism, 36:4 (2025), https://doi.org/10.1080/10455752.2025.2568135
  26. See Holland, Mary. The Case Against Scientific Retraction (29 June 2026). https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/case-against-scientific-retraction-mary-holland-guest-editorial/
  27. See Wakefield, Andrew J., MD. Callous Disregard: Autism and Vaccines – The Truth Behind a Tragedy. New York: Skyhorse, 2017. A note in large type on the copyright page reads “NOT FOR SALE IN THE UNITED KINGDOM.” See also Wallis, “The Impact of Censorship” (note 3).
  28. Less spectacular but no less alarming is the impact of rising ocean temperatures. See Hunziker, Robert. Ocean Death Countdown. Counterpunch (18 Sept. 2026), https://www.counterpunch.org/2026/09/18/ocean-death-countdown/

Article information

Authors

How to cite

Wallis, V., 2026. Toward a Unified Public Health and Environmental Agenda: Reflections in the Wake of COVID-19. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0654

Record

Journal
Medical Research Archives
Section
Research Articles
Published
31 October 2026
ISSN
2375-1924
Downloads
105

Copyright and licence

Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.