Key findings
- 26 + 42patients and healthcare professionals interviewed at a 600-bed hospital in Vienna between August 2019 and September 2022
- 3main groups of patients who may benefit from volunteer support: social factors, illness- and hospital-related factors, and end-of-life-related factors
- No visitsfrom relatives, or only a few: by far the most frequently cited group that would benefit, according to both patients and healthcare staff
- Around a fifthof the statements about a lack of visits explicitly linked it to the patients’ age
Abstract
Hospitalisation can disrupt patients’ everyday lives and may insufficiently address their social and emotional needs. Volunteer patient support can complement professional healthcare by providing conversation, companionship and practical assistance. Previous research on VPS in acute care hospitals has focused predominantly on geriatric and cognitively impaired patients and on care-related activities.
This study examines which patient groups may benefit from VPS, with particular attention to the role of conversation-based interpersonal interaction and social support.
An exploratory qualitative study was conducted at a 600-bed hospital in Vienna between August 2019 and September 2022. Problem-centred interviews based on Witzel’s method were conducted with 26 patients and 42 healthcare professionals from different clinical departments and professional groups. Participants were selected to maximise diversity of perspectives. Data were analysed using qualitative content analysis according to Kuckartz and subsequently subjected to expert validation.
Three groups of potential beneficiaries were identified, each characterised by a different key factor: the first group was defined by the frequency and helpfulness of interaction with their own relatives, including those who preferred a conversation with a neutral person or welcomed such a person as an additional means of communication. The second group focused on illness-related aspects and comprised patients with prolonged or repeated hospital stays, as well as those experiencing particularly high levels of stress due to life-altering illnesses or unexpected hospital admissions. The main aspect of the third group was its proximity to the end of life which included older patients, patients with dementia and those at the end of life. However, participants emphasised substantial individual differences in patients’ need and willingness to engage in conversation, as well as in their preferred conversation partners and timing.
The findings suggest that volunteer patient support should not be restricted to narrowly defined groups such as the very old, cognitively impaired or terminally ill. Social and emotional support may be relevant to hospitalised patients across age groups and clinical conditions. In line with the biopsychosocial model and patient-centred care, VPS should be considered a complementary component of dignified healthcare, with patients’ individual social and emotional needs guiding its provision.
Introduction
When a hospital stay becomes necessary, a person’s health is so severely impaired that carrying out everyday activities is subject to significant restrictions.1 At the same time, such a stay represents a disruption to daily life and exposes patients to many new experiences.2 Hospitals are complex institutions characterised by a high degree of specialisation and a focus on physical illnesses and medical expertise grounded in the natural sciences;3 these demand a great deal of adaptation from patients, as their structures are designed to maintain efficient workflows – including through the use of modern medical technology – whilst disregarding patients’ subjective well-being and psychosocial needs.4
As a further development of the previously dominant biomedical paradigm, the biopsychosocial approach takes psychological and social factors into account in the aetiology and treatment of disease, in addition to biological factors, and thus offers a more holistic approach to patient care. This not only meets the need for patients to be recognised as individuals within their own unique life contexts, beyond objectively diagnosable symptoms of illness, but also better addresses today’s challenges in healthcare, which lie more in lifestyle-related chronic and complex conditions than in infectious diseases.3 Patient-centred care can be understood as the practical implementation of the biopsychosocial paradigm; Gerteis et al. have defined six dimensions for this, which are supported by the IOM (now the National Academy of Medicine, NAM): 1) respect for patients’ values, preferences, and expressed needs; 2) coordination and integration; 3) information, communication, and education; 4) ensuring physical comfort; 5) emotional support; 6) involvement of family and friends.5,6
Within this patient-centred approach, volunteer patient support (VPS) can make a contribution: as a hospital visiting service, trained volunteers can offer practical, day-to-day support in the form of conversations, running errands and providing assistance, complementing the medical, nursing and therapeutic care on offer, and helping to improve patients' well-being during their hospital stay.7
The international research on VPS in acute care hospitals is limited; the relevant scientific literature focuses heavily on patient groups with a foreseeable, finite life expectancy – primarily geriatric patients, and within this group, predominantly those with dementia, as well as cancer patients. Furthermore, the research primarily examines care-related activities such as assistance with meals or mobility, whilst the social component is only recorded as a secondary outcome.8
This article, however, examines the importance of conversation-based interpersonal interaction within the context of social support provided by VPS as well as the question of whether this service can be of benefit to other target groups beyond the aforementioned limited group of patients.
Methods
Previous research into social support in the context of hospital stays in general, and VPS in particular, has focused on narrowly defined target groups, which primarily represent the peripheral or extreme areas of clinical care. As part of a more comprehensive study on the potential impact and role of VPS,8 the question of whether – and, if so, which – other patient groups might benefit from the voluntary support services was addressed only in passing; this is explored in greater depth here. To this end, the exploratory approach of the qualitative research paradigm was adopted, which allows one to abstract from subjective accounts of personal experiences to identify broader, trans-individual significance.
At a 600-bed hospital in Vienna, between August 2019 and September 2022, 26 patients and 42 healthcare workers were interviewed on, amongst other things, their subjective perceptions of VPS and the presumed target groups for this service (the lengthy duration of the survey is due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which temporarily prevented the implementation of VPS; the required ethics committee approval had to be extended three times). Although the data was collected four years ago, the results can be considered valid, as the underlying circumstances have remained the same – neither the structures nor the general procedures at the clinic, nor the range of services offered by VPS have changed; the composition of the patient population and their clinical presentations have also remained unaltered, and therefore their social needs are likely to have remained the same as well.
In both groups of respondents, the aim was to achieve maximum diversity so that different perspectives on the subject under investigation could be captured using a triangulation approach9 – patients of different ages and with varying lengths of stay in departments of dermatology/venerology, gynaecology, general surgery, neurosurgery, nephrology/diabetology, gastroenterology/hepatology, cardiology and neurology; and staff from various healthcare professions such as medicine, nursing and therapy at different hierarchical levels (front-line staff and those in management roles).
The interviews were conducted using a problem-centred structured interview based on Witzel’s method,10 an interview technique that allows for questions of varying scope and thus provides scope both for narrative passages that reveal the affected person’s system of relevance, and for theory-guided as well as comprehension-checking follow-up questions, which may include tightly guided questions to narrow down a particular aspect of the discussion. This inductive-deductive exchange – which ideally emerges in a positive atmosphere of benevolent interest created by the researcher – enables a deep immersion in the phenomenon under investigation and the generation of rich information. The interviews were all conducted in a protected setting, although disruptions could not always be avoided. Patients were interviewed the day before their discharge; appointments were arranged with healthcare professionals. On average, an interview lasted approximately 30 minutes; no interview was cut short.
Once transcribed, these interviews were analysed using qualitative content analysis according to Kuckartz,11 a method in which the respondents’ statements are coded and organised into a system of categories that forms the basis for a structured content analysis in which the key messages are categorised. The results were also submitted to individuals responsible for coordinating voluntary work at other hospitals outside Vienna for critical review as part of the expert validation process.
Results
Three main groups, each comprising several sub-groups, were identified. Table 1 provides an overview, which is explained in more detail in the text.
Table 1. Patient groups with benefit from VPS
| Patient groups with benefit from VPS | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Social factors | No visits | Non-helpful visits | Additional benefit to visits |
| Illness-/hospital- related factors | Long stay | Life-changing diagnosis/treatment | Avoidance of professionals |
| End-of-life-related factors | Reminescence | Dementia | Terminally ill |
Group 1: Social factors – frequency and perceived support from visits by relatives
By far the most frequently cited group that would benefit from VPS, according to both the patients surveyed and healthcare staff, was those who received no visits from relatives, or only a few.
“There are, after all, quite a lot – or rather more – people who perhaps don’t have much contact with the outside world, no family or fewer friends or whatever, and with whom they can then talk – about their worries, and about the things they’re going through, the ideas they have – and I think it really does help them if there’s someone there they can talk to about these things.” (IP 66, patient, item 22)
In some cases, it was acknowledged that relatives might live far away, be kept busy with work and everyday responsibilities, and therefore not visit, or not visit very often.
“There are always people on the ward who don’t get any visitors. Or at least that’s the feeling – that nobody ever comes. Sometimes that impression is misleading; they might come on a Monday, and at the weekend the relatives are there, but nobody was there all week, for example.” (IP 39, head nurse, item 46)
For the most part, this criterion of infrequent visits was mentioned regardless of age. In around a fifth of the statements regarding a lack of visits, these were explicitly linked to the patients’ age, which served as the reason for them being alone – deceased partners, friends who were themselves ill or immobile… were said to be a common occurrence as people grew older.
“Patients are often on their own simply because, due to their age, they no longer have many relatives, or perhaps they no longer have a partner because their husband or wife has passed away, and for them it’s simply wonderful when someone sits down and listens to them. They feel that they are being noticed.” (IP 21, head nurse, item 10)
In the case of patients receiving visits from relatives, it was occasionally pointed out that this was not always in the patient’s best interests. The relationship might be distant or fraught with conflict, and even well-meaning relatives might be of little help.
“When a young woman – obviously a daughter – turns up at half past five in the evening and is so curt that I thought to myself, ‘She’s only doing this because she has to’, then I think to myself, ‘Something’s not right in that family.’” (IP 59, patient, item 62)
“Because if you’ve just had a row with a family member, then a neutral person to whom you can pour your heart out is still better, because within the family, if I’ve had a row with them, what am I supposed to do? It just carries on, doesn’t it? Whereas if I have someone neutral to whom I can tell this, and if I just tell them that.” (IP 3, head nurse, Item 32)
“Relatives are close too, but yes – you know them well, and they often mean too well and try to give too much encouragement, saying ‘you must do this and you must do that again, and that this and that is the case, and that you need to sort this and that out again, and that you’ll come home again’ – they might just be a bit too close, perhaps you really just need an outsider for a change, someone you can simply have a chat with, without your closest relatives – who mean well, but often mean too well – making you feel pressured.” (IP 46, therapist, item 22)
Also, in cases where patients would prefer to discuss certain matters with a neutral person rather than with a close relative – because they do not wish to place a burden on their relatives or fear a reaction they feel would be of little help to them – VPS is a good alternative to contacting relatives.
“On the one hand, there’s always the fact that patients want to protect their relatives – or, conversely, with cancer patients, it’s often the relatives who want to protect the patient, because you can’t expect too much of them, you can’t tell them everything; it works a bit differently with the volunteers - patients can really talk about anything that’s close to their hearts, and I don’t think that’s always really possible with family members. Of course, there are also family members who – let’s say – perhaps don’t feel that close a bond, but are simply fulfilling their duty, and the basis for the conversation is accordingly different.” (IP 10, head nurse, item 86)
“The volunteers are a bit on the outside; they’re mostly lay people – or almost always – and they’re not directly involved in the day-to-day running of the facility. So perhaps it does benefit the patients in that they can talk to an outsider who isn’t as close to them as family. Because you talk differently to family, after all. I mean, lots of people say, ‘I’d really like to talk to someone about it’, […] but I can’t do that with my husband or my daughter or whoever, because they’d immediately get all worked up or something. […] That’s the kind of thing I hear – someone saying, ‘I’d really love to talk to someone who’s completely uninvolved’ – and the volunteers do fulfil that need, or are able to fulfil it.” (IP 40, doctor, item 28)
On occasion, it became clear that even patients who had a good relationship with their relatives – who visited them frequently – appreciated the contact with VPS: the service provided by VPS conveys an image of a hospital that is committed to looking after non-medical concerns as well, and offers an opportunity for new ideas.
“It gave me the impression that the hospital somehow / that social well-being is a major priority. That was the first thing I thought, because I came in, saw this and thought, ‘Ah, they’ve got this here too, wonderful; the hospital is part of the community, the community is part of the hospital – it’s lovely that this exists here as well.’” (IP 57, patient, item 76)
“Personally, I don’t feel lonely – but let’s say you have a conversation with someone else, because you keep hearing the same things over and over again from the relatives; there isn’t much to talk about anyway, as everyone knows each other, so perhaps you’ll hear something new.” (IP 44, patient, item 76)
“My wife is my wife – that’s a family matter – and it’s a lifelong intimacy, whereas the visiting service opens up a whole other world, I think.” (IP 54, patient, item 82)
Furthermore, VPS could also be used to ease the burden on relatives, who would otherwise have to travel long distances and who, thanks to the service, would know that the patient is being well looked after.
“When you know that if you’re admitted to hospital, you might be able to relax a bit more there – or perhaps tell someone else who’s coming to visit from far away, ‘No, I’ve got someone coming round for half an hour anyway’.” (IP 61, patient, item 26)
Group 2: Illness- and hospital-related factors – length and frequency of stays, perceived stress
Reference was made relatively frequently to patients with longer stays, for whom VPS could also be of great benefit. Once the acute phase has subsided and the need for medical treatment diminishes, VPS could meet the social needs that are now becoming more pronounced, or provide a change of pace in a hospital routine that is often described as boring.
“The longer the hospital stay, the less of it [VPS, ed.] is too much, because once the acute examinations are complete and the nursing staff aren’t really in a position to chat with the patients – for whatever reason, whether it’s because the patient still needs antibiotics or is still on a drip – the longer the stay, the more the visiting service actually comes into its own, I think.” (IP 50, doctor, item 38)
“If I were lying here for weeks on end, I’d probably really look forward to it – I think it would be the sort of appointment I could look forward to each week. That really does keep your spirits up.” (IP 57, patient, item 62)
In some cases, reference was made to patients with chronic conditions who require repeated hospital admissions and who would be happy to take advantage of this service.
“Many of them come back to us time and again, and by then they’ve got to know some of the volunteers, […] and they’re always delighted when the visiting service comes.” (IP 22, nurse, item 42)
In addition, the VPS was also considered to be of great benefit to those who feel burdened or appear to be under strain, whether due to their illness or other life circumstances.
“There are some patients where you realise they need someone to talk to; they’d like to confide in someone, they just want to get their troubles or problems off their chest.” (IP 16, head nurse, item 4)
“There was also a volunteer who came in; the gentleman was about 80, give or take, but he was in a bit of a bad way, and I think he really needed that […] the volunteer who came in and always talked to him and always brought him something or other – I think he needed that too; the patient needed it. In that situation, it really did help.” (IP 31, patient, items 70–76)
Sometimes patients spoke of unexpected hospital admissions and how the associated stress had affected their well-being – VPS was perceived as something special in these instances.
“Due to the kind of physiological stress caused by a heart attack or similar, mental function doesn’t quite remain the same as it usually is. […] because you are confronted with issues such as death and dying, etc., so that one then reacts emotionally, for example by bursting into tears, and that may perhaps seem distressing, but ultimately it is a genuine emotion being expressed by a person, which actually shows that they have been accepted once again, and that sense of belonging that the visiting service can provide is, I believe, something very important, yes.” (IP 54, patient, item 18)
In the context of emotional distress, healthcare staff repeatedly cited VPS – in its aforementioned role as an external, neutral point of contact only loosely integrated into hospital operations – as a possible option when patients showed reservations towards specialist staff; some would refuse contact with the psychological services. In such cases, VPS would be a good way for patients to discuss the concerns weighing on their minds without exposing themselves to the perceived risk of stigmatisation.
“We often have patients who are really, really seriously ill, but who often don’t want to see a psychologist, and who often talk to complete strangers about things that are weighing on their minds – and they simply feel better because they often don’t want to talk about it with us either. And we can tell that they really benefit from this – that is, from the fact that someone [one of the volunteers, ed.] is there.” (IP 49, nurse, item 16)
Group 3: end-of-life-related factors – geriatric patients, those with dementia and the terminally ill
Advanced age alone, regardless of whether or not the person had social contacts, was also mentioned on several occasions as a characteristic of those who would benefit from VPS.
“I think it’s a change of pace for older people when someone comes round, you know, they’re just happy, or when she says, ‘I’m a volunteer,’ and she sits down and chats a bit and just has a bit of a natter.” (IP 56, patient, item 88)
In this context, age-specific characteristics such as looking back on the past or a slowing down of thought and speech were highlighted.
“They often talk about the past too, about how things used to be for them, or they tend to be a bit sad because they’re not doing well now, because they’re in pain, and they’re simply grateful when someone really turns their attention to them, makes contact and talks to them; they’re often really just simple conversations, so to speak, but for the patients it’s actually very helpful.” (IP 21, head nurse, Item 8)
“Older people often can’t speak very quickly anymore and need time to open up; and, as I said, they can also talk about […] which is nevertheless important for the patient.” (IP 50, doctor, item 30)
Young patients were only occasionally specifically mentioned as a target group for VPS.
“There’s always a need for conversation, especially amongst older people, but also amongst younger people; unfortunately, this is all becoming more common – younger people also need that attention and all that, because life is so much more fast-paced these days.” (IP 15, head nurse, item 76)
As a subgroup of older patients, healthcare staff also mentioned, in each case with only a few instances, patients who are disoriented or suffering from dementia, as well as the terminally ill, as further potential target groups. These differ from the patients mentioned so far in terms of their responsiveness, in that the individuals concerned are significantly cognitively impaired or are in a state of unconsciousness. The conversation-based approach of the VPS faces the challenge here of finding a different form of communication.
“We’ve had two rather difficult patients here for a few weeks now – two who were completely confused and suffering from dementia – and the nursing staff really had their hands full, but even there we had tremendous support from the volunteers, who sat down with them and, I don’t know, looked through the newspaper with them or helped them with their meals and things like that, you could really tell that these dementia patients, who would otherwise just wander about aimlessly and feel lost in the hospital, had somehow found some peace because people were spending time with them, and they really appreciated it.” (IP 2, doctor, Item 15)
With regard to this particular group of patients, challenges and the need for special coordination between volunteers and healthcare staff were also discussed.
“They [the volunteers, ed.] have absolutely no idea what they’re going to find. Of course, it may well be that the person has dementia and is completely unable to communicate with them, and they often have to work that out during the conversation – that perhaps there’s simply no way to connect with them.” (IP 53, nurse, item 6)
“You know yourself that there are people like that: those who still manage to hide it well, who then go on telling tall tales. […] People with dementia are becoming increasingly common and it’s becoming more and more of an issue – especially those who try to compensate for this dementia; they’re already aware of it and try to cope, but then it just becomes extremely difficult – communication, that is – because if you don’t bring it up, you don’t even notice it, and I believe… yes, but you just have to talk to one another as you always do; you have to talk to one another.” (IP 16, head nurse, items 26–30)
A similar attitude is also evident with regard to dying patients – on the one hand, VPS was certainly seen as beneficial here:
“Because I’ve been unconscious twice myself, I know very well that even in the deepest state of unconsciousness you’re still aware of everything, and I always give them the tip: ‘There’s a dying patient in that room; go in and give them a stroke. They can’t reply anymore,’ I say, ‘but people are still aware of everything.’” (IP 1, head nurse, item 47)
On the other hand, the staff was well aware of the issues involved.
“I can’t just drag every volunteer – or anyone, for that matter – into a situation like that and simply say ‘it would be nice’, because you have to be able to cope with sitting with someone who is dying.” (IP 39, head nurse, item 22)
Individual differences
In addition to the categorisations of patients described above – who were regarded as the target group for VPS – it was repeatedly pointed out that, regardless of these criteria, there are also individual differences with regard to the need to communicate.
“It depends on the type of person. Some people are used to coping quite well on their own, even in difficult situations. For some people, of course, it’s better if they can lie there and talk about things, and there’s also a third group who are used to talking, talking, talking – and it’s absolutely certain that there’s something they can and are allowed to talk about.” (IP 45, patient, item 72)
Patients also vary greatly in terms of their preferred conversation partner and the most suitable time for a conversation.
“It really does vary; there are patients here who are less keen to talk to someone from outside [meaning VPS, ed.] than to a nurse, for example, but there are certainly also patients who prefer to talk to someone from outside, who might then be more open or simply prefer to talk about personal matters that aren’t directly related to their illness.” (IP 36, nurse, item 18)
“It really does vary, doesn’t it? Some patients… it always depends on what sort of illness they have, what diagnosis they’ve just been given; some need to talk, others don’t at all; they just want to be left in peace, only come round after a few days, or cry quietly to themselves, or only discuss it with their relatives or visitors.” (IP 24, nurse, item 90)
“That’s always the thing – whether it’s picked up at the right time. […] From your side, too, so to speak, it must be recognised whether the person wants to have a chat for half an hour.” (IP 61, patient, item 44)
Sometimes, the need for a conversation only becomes clear when volunteers themselves make contact with patients.
“Some people need it, others simply don’t […] because the conversation is probably missing for those who might need it, whereas we don’t even know whether they need it.” (IP 7, head nurse, Pos. 74–76)
Discussion
The study investigated which patient groups, in the opinion of patients and healthcare staff, would benefit from volunteer support. The findings show that these are primarily those with limited social contact – that is, patients who receive no visitors or whose relatives are currently unable to provide the support they require. The second main group consists of patients requiring long-term hospitalisation or experiencing significant distress. Only the third group comprises those with age-related limitations, or the terminally ill.
When compared with international literature on the use of volunteers in acute care hospitals, it is striking that the target groups identified here differ from those that have been the focus of research to date or to whom VPS has apparently been primarily allocated. In previous studies, VPS care was predominantly investigated for geriatric patients – often in connection with care-related activities such as meal assistance and mobilisation, or with a focus on dementia or delirium; clinical outcomes such as nutritional intake, fall rates, episodes of delirium, length of stay, readmission rates and cost savings were the main focus8. The difference in target groups may be due to the fact that previous research has been guided more by clinical algorithms, the need to relieve the workload of healthcare staff, and the economic considerations of the hospital operator than by the subjective well-being of patients.
The groups identified in this study may both be associated with advanced old age, but are not limited to it. The fact that young patients were scarcely mentioned specifically does not mean that they cannot fall into the group of those with inadequate social resources or those requiring long-term care.
With regard to social isolation and feelings of loneliness, Surkalim et al.12 show, in a Europe-wide comparison, that loneliness generally increases with age, although younger people may also be affected, with significant differences within Europe. Vasile & Aaartsen13 point out that loneliness levels among the very elderly fell in the 2014–2023 comparison, whilst they rose slightly among young people. In German-speaking countries, recent surveys show that, since the COVID-19 pandemic, loneliness has led to an increase in feelings of loneliness among young people14 – in Germany, in fact, more young people than older people feel lonely.15
With regard to existing but unhelpful social contacts, Thoits,16 for example, points out that relatives are affected both emotionally and in very practical terms in their own daily lives, and may tend to influence patients inappropriately by trivialising their condition or exerting pressure for a rapid recovery. According to Christenfeld et al.,17 the impact of social support works both ways: both the provision and the absence of support from family members have a stronger effect than that provided by strangers. In this respect, successful social support from strangers or volunteers is more helpful than the absence or failure of support from close relatives.
Hospitalisation-related stress is a phenomenon that has been recognised for decades and can have a detrimental effect on pain perception and recovery.18–21 Symptoms of stress such as depression, anxiety and disorientation can affect patients of all ages, regardless of their condition, although vulnerable individuals such as older people, children and those with a history of mental health conditions are at a significantly higher risk.2 Long-term hospital stays due to chronic, life-altering or even life-threatening conditions can also significantly impair patients’ mental well-being and may be accompanied by emotional exhaustion; the hospital is then perceived less as a place of healing and more as a constant reminder of their frailty. Psychosocial support, provided in addition to medical treatment as an integral part of patient care, is regarded as particularly essential in this context.22 Unexpected hospital admissions, which are often accompanied by a stay in intensive care, also act as a major stressor.23 In such cases VPS can help to alleviate the experience of stress, optimise patient care with a view to a holistic approach, and make the conditions in the highly complex hospital setting more bearable for everyone.8 It does not compete with relatives, but can complement and relieve them when their hopes of a speedy recovery are not realised and they also show signs of fatigue due to their prolonged hospital stay.
As people get older, hospital admissions – particularly multiple admissions within a year and longer lengths of stay – become more likely1,24; it is therefore understandable that greater attention is being paid to this group, although, according to the available evidence, age alone is not the sole criterion for identifying the target group for VPS. Rather, certain characteristics may arise in combination with age that make these patients receptive to VPS. For example, during a conversation, VPS can address the potential need to reflect on the past – reminiscence interventions can help improve well-being by activating memories spanning the patient’s lifetime, thereby contributing to a sense of identity and promoting problem-solving skills and emotional regulation.25,26
The group of older patients also includes those with dementia27 – the fact that dementia patients were scarcely mentioned as a target group for VPS in the present study is surprising in light of the author’s day-to-day professional experience: volunteers come into contact with dementia patients on a daily basis. It may be that, for healthcare staff, the focus is primarily on those patients with advanced dementia who stand out due to motor restlessness or agitation, expressed through shouting, and who are particularly demanding in day-to-day care – however, they are equally challenging for laypeople (even those trained in communication and validation), and this explains the assumption that they are not a suitable target group for VPS. Patients with early-stage dementia, in which verbal communication is possible, on the other hand, may not even be considered at all or may be categorised within the larger group of elderly patients. Volunteers are, in fact, only marginally involved with the dying; apart from staff’s reluctance to deploy volunteers here, patients might be transferred to a palliative or hospice care setting, where VPS forms part of standard care28 or to the ICU, both of which were not part of the study.
Of course, the categories may overlap – older patients may be affected by long-term stays, younger patients may be terminally ill, and so on. The classification used is based on the respondents’ statements, and where age was not specifically mentioned, it was not taken into account, thus prioritizing utterances coming first to mind. This also means that older patients could have been implicitly included when the discussion turned to missed visits – though the same applies to younger patients, etc.
The finding presented here – that social support provided by VPS is not always accepted by everyone, regardless of age or illness – is corroborated in the literature: Cutrona & Russell29 highlight, through the ‘matching thesis’, the need for a good fit between the support sought and the support actually provided; Thoits16 describes the different resources that helpers are able to provide based on their respective relationship with the recipient of help. Bolger & Amarel30 assume that support is more likely to be accepted if the recipient is aware that they need help and does not feel that an unwanted offer of help undermines their self-esteem. According to Kosits8, VPS, as outsiders in an unburdened relationship with patients, largely succeed in responding to their current needs and in accepting rejection.
The limitations of this study lie in its design as a single-centre study and in the author’s dual role as a researcher and volunteer coordinator. The former could imply limited validity of the findings – this was addressed by having the results reviewed and confirmed by volunteer coordinators at other hospitals under different governing bodies. The second limitation could mean that healthcare staff interviewed, who also know the author as a colleague, provide socially desirable responses. To counteract this, the questioning techniques available within the problem-centred interview approach were utilised to the full, and critical follow-up questions were asked where appropriate.
Conclusion
Notwithstanding the previous focus of research on VPS in acute care hospitals, the present study shows that it is not only the very elderly and the terminally ill, or those with impaired cognitive functions, who benefit from VPS. The common perception of lonely elderly ladies as a target group is also broadened here – elderly ladies are not always lonely, nor are lonely people always elderly. Whilst elderly people may constitute a large proportion of patients in an acute care hospital, this does not preclude the need to consider the remaining patients as well, particularly in the context of a patient-centred approach.
Given that social care is understood as a universal human need which, in accordance with the biopsychosocial model of health, cannot be viewed in isolation from biological and psychological processes,31,32 it is untenable to restrict it to illnesses and conditions in which the scope for curative medical treatment is severely limited – it should not be seen as a stopgap in the absence of other options, but as an integral part of dignified patient care.33,34 Diagnoses and treatments that entail the need for a change in lifestyle can be just as existentially challenging as the anticipated approach of one’s own end of life.
Regarding the six aspects of patient-centred care, VPS can contribute in several of them: volunteers are trained to treat patients with respect and without judgement, and to seek to empathically understand their subjective perspective and their needs, which also encompasses cultural and social backgrounds. By acting as a communication bridge between patients and healthcare staff, VPS can support patients’ need for information regarding their condition and treatment by relaying their concerns to staff. The same applies to physical wellbeing and requests for pain relief. Furthermore, VPS proves to be a valuable resource, particularly with regard to emotional support – its strengths include support with emotion-oriented stress management and facilitating experiences of wholeness and belonging.8 Entirely in keeping with patient-centred care, the integration of VPS should be viewed not as an ‘opponent, but as an ally in the pursuit of optimised medicine’35.
Declarations
- Statement on conflicts of interest
- The author works as a volunteer coordinator at the hospital where she carried out the study
- Funding statement
- The researcher receives no remuneration whatsoever
Research was conducted in German; quotations had to be translated for this article.
Bibliography
- Amo-Saus E, Martinez-Lacoba R, Pardo-García I, Moya-Martínez P. Hospitalizations and doctor visits among older adults in Europe: cross-country differences using a multilevel approach. Gac Sanit. 2025;39(Special Issue on Health Economics). doi:10.1016/j.gaceta.2025.102465
- Abdelfadil Ismail M, Abdullah Alharbi RS, Muhyi Alshehri AA, et al. Hospitalization’s Impact on Patient’s Mental and Emotional Health: Systematic Review. TPM - Testiing, Psychometrics, Methology in Applied Psychology. 2025;32(S4):2321-2328. https://www.tpmap.org/
- Feo R, Kitson A. Promoting patient-centred fundamental care in acute healthcare systems. Int J Nurs Stud. Elsevier Ltd. 2016;57:1-11. doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.01.006
- DiGioia A, Greenhouse PK, Levison TJ. Patient and family-centered collaborative care: An orthopaedic model. In: Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. Vol 463. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2007:13-19. doi:10.1097/BLO.0b013e31814d4d76
- Institute of Medicine. Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century. (The National Academies Press, ed.). National Academies Press; 2001. doi:10.17226/10027
- Tzelepis F, Sanson-Fisher RW, Zucca AC, Fradgley EA. Measuring the quality of patient-centered care: Why patient-reported measures are critical to reliable assessment. Patient Prefer Adherence. 2015;9:831-835. doi:10.2147/PPA.S81975
- Kosits G. Ehrenamtliche Patientenbetreuung im Akutkrankenhaus. Universum Innere Medizin. 2024;(8):18-20. Accessed July 22, 2026. https://www.medmedia.at/univ-innere-medizin/wirkpotenziale-ehrenamtlicher-patientenbetreuung-im-akutkrankenhaus/
- Kosits G. Ehrenamtliche Patient:innenbetreuung im Akutkrankenhaus. Lambertus; 2024.
- Denzin NK. Triangulation. In: The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.; 2015. doi:10.1002/9781405165518.wbeost050.pub2
- Witzel A. Das problemzentrierte Interview. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research. January 31, 2000. Accessed September 29, 2019. http://www.qualitative-research.net/index.php/fqs/article/view/1132/2519
- Kuckartz U. Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Methoden, Praxis, Computerunterstützung. 2. Auflage. Beltz Juventa; 2014.
- Surkalim DL, Luo M, Eres R, et al. The prevalence of loneliness across 113 countries: Systematic review and meta-analysis. The BMJ. BMJ Publishing Group. 2022;376. doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-067068
- Vasile M, Aartsen M. Loneliness Prevalence in Different Age Groups in Europe. In: International Perspectives on Aging. Vol 47. Springer Publishing Company; 2025:89-113. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-94565-6_5
- Bundesministerium für Arbeit, Soziales, Gesundheit, Pflege und Konsumentenschutz. Einsamkeit in Österreich. 2025. Accessed July 23, 2026. https://www.statistik.at/fileadmin/publications/Einsamkeit_Bericht-20251209.pdf
- Luhmann M, Schäfer B, Steinmayr R. Einsamkeit Junger Menschen 2024 Im Europäischen Vergleich. 2024. doi:10.11586/2024167
- Thoits PA. Mechanisms linking social ties and support to physical and mental health. J Health Soc Behav. 2011;52(2):145-161. doi:10.1177/0022146510395592
- Christenfeld N, Gerin W, Linden W, et al. Social Support Effects on Cardiovascular Reactivity : Is a Stranger as Effective as a Friend ? Psychosom Med. 1997;59(4):388-398.
- Chhari N, Mehta SC. Stress Among Patients During Hospitalization: a Study from Central India. National Journal of Community Medicine│Volume. 2016;7(4):247-277.
- Boey JP, Boey KW. Stress Associated with Hospitalisation among Rural Patients in Malaysia. International Medical Journal. 2016;23(6):620-623. http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=cin20&AN=120656000&site=ehost-live
- Kotrotsiou E, Theodosopoulou E, Raftopoulos V. How do patients experience stress caused by hospitalisation and how do nurses perceive this stress experienced by patients? A comparative study. ICUs and Nursing Web Journal. Published online 2001.
- Volicer BJ. Hospital stress and patient reports of pain and physical status. J Human Stress. 1978;4(2):28-37. doi:10.1080/0097840X.1978.9934984
- Alsharef AS, Al Jamahir AY, Alqarni MS, et al. Impact of Long-Term Hospitalization on the Emotional Well-Being of Chronic Inpatients and the Role of Nursing and physicians: Review. Journal of International Crisis and Risk Communication Research. 2024;7(S7):63-69. doi:10.63278/jicrcr.vi.1220
- Couette M, Gendreau S, Boishardy MC, et al. Mental health outcomes at intensive care unit discharge: prevalence, mediators and risk factors. Ann Intensive Care. 2025;15(138):1-9. doi:10.1186/s13613-025-01545-w
- Schmuker C, Leporis J, Günster C. Erkrankungshäufigkeiten und die Inanspruchnahme des Gesundheitssystems alter und hochbetagter Menschen im Überblick. In: Klauber J, Wasem J, Beivers A, Mostert C, Scheller-Kreinsen D, eds. Krankenhausreport 2025. Springer; 2025:27-48. doi:10.1007/978-3-662-70947-4_2
- Bohlmeijer E, Roemer M, Cuijpers P, Smit F. The effects of reminiscence on psychological well-being in older adults: A meta-analysis. Aging Ment Health. 2007;11(3):291-300. doi:10.1080/13607860600963547
- Lenz HJ, Zimmermann S, Forstmeier S. Der Lebensrückblick und Traumafolgestörungen aus der Perspektive der Lebensspanne. Trauma & Gewalt. 2020;14(4):288-302. doi:10.21706/tg-14-4-288
- Kirchen-Peters S. Demenz als pflegerische Herausforderung im Krankenhaus. In: Klauber J, Wasem J, Beivers A, Mostert C, Scheller-Kreinsen D, eds. Krankenhausreport 2025. Springer; 2025:107-119. doi:10.1007/978-3-662-70947-4_7
- Dachverband Hospiz Österreich. Hospiz-Palliative-Care - Ehrenamt in Österreich und Europa. August 2025. Accessed July 24, 2026. https://www.hospiz.at/hospiz-palliative-care/ehrenamt-in-oesterreich-und-europa/
- Cutrona CE, Russell DW. Type of social support and specific stress: Toward a theory of optimal matching. Social support: An interactional view. 1990;(January 2015):319-366. https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=psyh&AN=1990-97699-013&site=ehost-live
- Bolger N, Amarel D. Effects of social support visibility on adjustment to stress: Experimental evidence. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2007;92(3):458-475. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.92.3.458
- Obrecht W. Umrisse Einer Biopsychosoziokulturellen Theorie Menschlicher Bedürfnisse. 2005. http://www.freies-institut-tpsa.com/documents/Obrecht, Werner A. - Umrisse einer biopsychosoziokulturellen Theorie menschlicher Bedürfnisse.pdf
- Pauls H. Das biopsychosoziale Modell – Herkunft und Aktualität. 2013;1(1):17. http://www.resonanzen-journal.org/index.php/resonanzen/article/view/191
- Ervin K, Moore S. Rural nurses’ perceptions of a volunteer program in an acute setting: Volunteers delivering person-centred care for patients with dementia and delirium. Open J Nurs. 2014;04(01):27-33. doi:10.4236/ojn.2014.41005
- Ayton D, Moran C, Berkovic D, et al. The Volunteer Dementia and Delirium Care (VDDC) program: An exploration of perceived barriers and enablers to implementation in an acute and subacute metropolitan hospital. Australias J Ageing. 2019;00:1-10. doi:10.1111/ajag.12726
- Egger JW. Das biopsychosoziale Krankheitsmodell - Grundzüge eines wissenschaftlich begründeten ganzheitlichen Verständnisses von Krankheit. Psychologische Medizin. 2005;2:3-12. http://www.bpsmed.net/_data/doc/literature/1Egger_bpsMod05.pdf%0Ahttp://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/malq.19970430114%0Ahttp://arxiv.org/abs/1204.5409%0Ahttp://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.86.134421
Article information
Authors
- Kosits GerlindeWiener Gesundheitsverbund/Klinik LandstraßeCorresponding author · [email protected]
How to cite
Kosits, G., 2026. Beyond Age and Diagnosis: Volunteer Patient Support as a Patient-Centred Approach to Social and Emotional Needs in Acute Care. Medical Research Archives, [online] 14(10). https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.2026.0655
Record
- Journal
- Medical Research Archives
- Issue
- Vol 14 No 10 (2026)
- Section
- Research Articles
- Published
- 31 October 2026
- ISSN
- 2375-1924
- Downloads
- 59
Copyright and licence
Published by the European Society of Medicine under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited.