The Meaning of Clinical Normality

Main Article Content

Christopher Boorse

Abstract

Many writers have called the term ‘normal’ highly ambiguous both in and out of medicine, especially between descriptive and normative meanings. But careful analysis shows that its ambiguity is much less than usually supposed. In fact, all correct nontechnical uses of ‘normal’ mean “typical” in some way – either typical, at least typical, or at most typical – and therefore express no value judgments except by contextual implication. The distinctive, purely medical use, as the opposite of ‘pathological’, is just a specialization of the second meaning, to at-least-typical biological part-function. As statisticians have often warned, one must not confuse this uniquely medical use with a general use formerly applied to clinical tests, in the term “normal range.” That term is misleading because the reference ranges of clinical variables entail nothing about pathology, for three reasons: besides resting on an arbitrary choice of a 95% central range, they are derived from apparently healthy populations, and the variables’ connection to underlying biological function can be very indirect. So the term “clinical abnormality” is best restricted to a diagnosed or diagnosable pathological condition. If so, true clinical normality contrasts with theoretical normality in some interesting ways: it may or may not correlate with disease severity; it is individual-relative; and it is partly determined by value judgments.

Article Details

How to Cite
BOORSE, Christopher. The Meaning of Clinical Normality. Medical Research Archives, [S.l.], v. 10, n. 7, july 2022. ISSN 2375-1924. Available at: <https://esmed.org/MRA/mra/article/view/2866>. Date accessed: 08 aug. 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.18103/mra.v10i7.2866.
Section
Research Articles

References

1 Murphy E A. The Logic of Medicine. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins; 1976. Second ed. 1997.

2 Oxford English Dictionary, Website 2000, entry ‘normal’. Accessed Dec. 23, 2021.

3 Boorse C. Health as a theoretical concept. Philosophy of Science. 1977;44:542-73.

4 ----------. A rebuttal on health. In Humber JM, Almeder RF, What is Disease? Totowa, NJ. Humana Press; 1997:1-134.

5 ----------. Concepts of health. In D VanDeVeer, T Regan, ed. Health Care Ethics: An Introduction. Philadelphia. Temple University Press; 1987:359-93.

6 -----------. A second rebuttal on health. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 2014;39:683-724.

7 Hacking I. The Taming of Chance. NY: Cambridge University Press; 1990.

8 Vacha J. Biology and the problem of normality. Scientia 1978;113:823-46.

9 Fricke C. Questioning the importance of being normal – an inquiry into the normative constraints of normality. Journal of Value Inquiry 2015;49:691-713.

10 Lewis CL, Short C. A Latin Dictionary. London: Oxford University Press; 1879.

11 Comte A. Système de Politique Positive. Paris; 1851.

12 Sober E. Evolution, population thinking, and essentialism. Philosophy of Science 1980;47:350-83.

13 ----------. The Nature of Selection. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1984.

14 Feinstein AR. Clinical Biostatistics. St. Louis: C.V.Mosby; 1977.

15 Jacobs DS, DeMott WR, Oxley, DK, ed. Jacobs & DeMott Laboratory Test Handbook. 5th ed. Hudson, OH: Lexi-Comp, Inc.; 2001.

16 Wilson DD. Manual of Laboratory & Diagnostic Tests. NY: McGraw-Hill; 2008.
17 Ravel R. Clinical Laboratory Medicine: Clinical Application of Laboratory Data. 5th ed. Chicago: Year Book Medical Publishers; 1989.

18 Galen, RS. Predictive value and efficiency of laboratory testing. Pediatric Clin North Am 1980;27(4):861-9.

19 Tresker S. Theoretical and clinical disease and the biostatistical theory. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biomedical Sciences 2020;82:1-11.

20 -----------. A typology of clinical conditions. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 2020;83:e1-e9.

21 Boorse C. Wakefield’s harm-based critique of the biostatistical theory. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy forthcoming.

22 Quaresima P et al. Incidental diagnosis of a pancreatic adenocarcinoma in a woman affected by gestational diabetes mellitus: case report and literature review. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM 2021 Nov;3(6):100471

23 Garcia AM et al. Late incidental diagnosis of intrapericardial teratoma – A case report. Revista Portuguesa de Cardiologia 2017;36(7-8):571e1-571.e4.

24 Faeez MS, Abdul Rashid AM. ‘Accidental’ diagnosis of a silent giant hydronephrosis. Journal of Urological Surgery 2018;5(3):206-08.

25 Verdoia M et al. Incidental diagnosis after a car accident. JACC Case Reports (2020); 2(15):2289-94.

26 Vacha J. German constitutional doctrine in the 1920s and 1930s and pitfalls of the contemporary conception of normality in biology and medicine. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1985;10:339-67.

27 Murphy EA. A scientific viewpoint on normalcy. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 1966;9:333-48.

28 Strößner C. (2015). Normality and majority: towards a statistical understanding of normality statements. Erkenntnis 2015;80:793-809.

29 Huber L. Norming normality: on scientific fictions and canonical visualisations. Medicine Studies 2011;3:41-52.

30 Boorse C. Concepts of health and disease. In: Gifford F, ed., Philosophy of Medicine, vol. 16 of the Handbook of Philosophy of Science. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 2011:13-64.

31 Rolf T. Normalität: Ein philosophischer Grundbegriff des 20. Jahrhunderts. Munich: Wilhelm Fink Verlag; 1999.

32 Vacha J. The Problem of Normality in Biology and Medicine. 2nd ed. (In Czech). Prague: Avicenum; 1983.

33 Garson J. A Critical Overview of Biological Functions. Springer; 2016.

34 Henry JB. Clinical Diagnosis and Management by Laboratory Methods. Philadelphia: W.B.Saunders; 2001.

35 Pagana KD, Pagana TJ. Mosby’s Manual of Diagnostic and Laboratory Tests. St. Louis, MO: Mosby; 1998.

36 Sacher RA, McPherson RA. Widmann’s Clinical Interpretation of Laboratory Tests. 11th ed. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis; 2000.

37 Murphy EA. The normal, and the perils of the sylleptic argument. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 1972;15:566-82.

38 Welch HG, Schwartz L, Woloshin S. Overdiagnosed: Making People Sick in the Pursuit of Health. NY: Random House; 2012.