Inter-Cultural Communication Skills Training in Medical Schools: A Systematic Review
Main Article Content
Background Effective intercultural communication skills are an essential graduate outcome for medical students in a globalised world. Educational theory would suggest that combining an understanding of cultural competence with patient centred communication skills through an experiential, immersive, reflective and longitudinal curriculum may be the most effective way to develop intercultural communication skills.
Aims To determine the scope and most effective teaching methods in training medical students in intercultural communication with ethnically diverse populations.
Method A systematic review of the literature was performed using the PRISMA Guidelines to identify articles that described methods for teaching intercultural communication to medical students. A search of the literature was performed in five databases: Cochrane, EMBASE, ERIC, PubMed and Web of Science. Relevant papers were interrogated for impact (Kirkpatrick level), quality (Colthart scale) and learning mechanism.
Results We found 22 studies that described teaching methods for developing intercultural communication for ethnically diverse people in medical schools. There were a diverse range of teaching methods, durations and time of delivery in the medical course. Better teaching interventions were underpinned by learning theory and usually included practice with standardised patients, reflection and immersive experiences with members of ethnically diverse communities. Evaluation of these studies was limited mostly to short term student satisfaction surveys or performance assessments which hampered determining their effectiveness.
Conclusion While there are indications that intercultural communication is best learnt as a continuum of cultural and communication skill development through immersive experiences, iteratively through medical school, there remains a need for high quality longitudinal studies to confirm this hypothesis.
The Medical Research Archives grants authors the right to publish and reproduce the unrevised contribution in whole or in part at any time and in any form for any scholarly non-commercial purpose with the condition that all publications of the contribution include a full citation to the journal as published by the Medical Research Archives.
2. Zanting A, Meershoek A, Frambach JM, Krumeich A. The ‘exotic other’ in medical curricula: Rethinking cultural diversity in course manuals. Medical Teacher. 2020; 42(7):791-798.
3. Sawatsky AP, Beckman TJ, Hafferty FW. Cultural competency, professional identity formation and transformative learning. Med Educ. 2017; 51(5):462-464.
4. Dogra N, Bhatti F, Ertubey C, Kelly M, Rowlands A, Singh D, Turner M.. Teaching diversity to medical undergraduates: Curriculum development, delivery and assessment. AMEE Guide No.103. Medical Teacher. 2016; 38(4):323-337.
5. Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2017. 2071.0 - Census of Population and Housing: Reflecting Australia - Stories from the Census, 2016. In: Statistics ABo, editor. Canberra.
6. Ferguson WJ, Candib LM. Culture, language, and the doctor-patient relationship. Fam Med. 2002; 34(5):353-361.
7. Alizadeh S, Chavan M. Perceived cultural distance in healthcare in immigrant intercultural medical encounters. International migration. 2020 Aug;58(4):231-54.
8. de Groot E, Schönrock-Adema J, Zwart D, Damoiseaux R, Van den Bogerd K, Diemers A, Grau Canét-Wittkampf C, Jaarsma D, Mol S, Bombeke K. Learning from patients about patient-centredness: A realist review: BEME Guide No. 60. Med Teach. 2020; 42(4):380-392.
9. Reitmanova S. Cross-cultural undergraduate medical education in North America: theoretical concepts and educational approaches. Teach Learn Med. 2011; 23(2):197-203.
10. General Medical Council. 2020. Outcomes for Graduates. United Kingdom: GMC; [accessed 26 June 20]. https://www.gmc-uk.org/education/standards-guidance-and-curricula/standards-and-outcomes/outcomes-for-graduates/outcomes-for-graduates.
11. Association of American Medical Colleges. Cultural Competence Education. Washington D.C.: AAMC; [accessed 28 June 20]. https://www.aamc.org/system/files/c/2/54338-culturalcomped.pdf. 2005.
12. Australian Medical Council. Standards for Assessment and Accreditation of Primary Medical Programs. Australian Capital Territory; [accessed 28 June 20]. https://www.amc.org.au/accreditation-and-recognition/accreditation-standards-and-procedures/; 2012
13. Frank J, Snell L, Sherbino J. CanMEDS 2015 Physician Competency Framework ;2015
14. Partnership MaRWsH.Migrant & Refugee Women's Health Partnership. 2019 [accessed 27 June 2020]. https://culturaldiversityhealth.org.au/.
15. Azad N, Power B, Dollin J, Chery S. Cultural sensitivity training in Canadian medical schools. Academic Medicine. 2002 Mar 1;77(3):222-8.
16. Dogra N, Reitmanova S, Carter-Pokras O. Teaching cultural diversity: current status in UK, US, and Canadian medical schools. Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2010 May;25:164-8
17. Green AR, Miller E, Krupat E, White A, Taylor WC, Hirsh DA, Wilson RP, Betancourt JR. Designing and implementing a cultural competence OSCE: lessons learned from interviews with medical students. Ethn Dis. 2007; 17(2):344-350.
18. Paternotte E, Scheele F, Seeleman CM, Bank L, Scherpbier AJ, van Dulmen S. Intercultural doctor-patient communication in daily outpatient care: relevant communication skills. Perspect Med Educ. 2016; 5(5):268-275.
19. Malau-Aduli, B. S., Ross, S., & Adu, M. D. Perceptions of intercultural competence and institutional intercultural inclusiveness among first year medical students: a 4-year study. BMC Medical Education, 2019; 19(1), 1-9.
20. Nameni A. Research into ethnocentrism and intercultural willingness to communicate of Iraqi and Iranian medical students in Iran. Journal of Intercultural Communication Research. 2020 Jan 2;49(1):61-85.
21. Teal CR, Street RL. Critical elements of culturally competent communication in the medical encounter: a review and model. Soc Sci Med. 2009; 68(3):533-543.
22. Pollozhani A, Kosevska E, Petkovski K, Memeti S, Limani B, Kasapinov B. Some aspects of culturally competent communication in health care in the Republic of Macedonia. Mater Sociomed. 2013; 25(4):250-254.
23. Brooks LA, Manias E, Bloomer MJ. Culturally sensitive communication in healthcare: A concept analysis. Collegian. 2019; 26(3):383-391.
24. Papadopoulos I, Tilki M, Ayling S. Cultural competence in action for CAMHS: Development of a cultural competence assessment tool and training programme. Contemporary Nurse. 2008 Apr 1;28(1-2):129-40.
25. Deardorff DK. Identification and assessment of intercultural competence as a student outcome of internationalization. Journal of studies in international education. 2006 Sep;10(3):241-66.
26. Betancourt J, Green A, Carrillo E. Cross-cultural care and communication. Boston: UpToDate; [accessed 2 December 2019]. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/cross-cultural-care-and-communication; 2018.
27. Green AR, Betancourt JR, Carrillo JE. Integrating Social Factors into Cross-cultural Medical Education. Academic Medicine. 2002; 77(3):193-197.
28. Paternotte E, van Dulmen S, van der Lee N, Scherpbier AJ, Scheele F. Factors influencing intercultural doctor-patient communication: a realist review. Patient Educ Couns. 2015; 98(4):420-445.
29. Betancourt JR. Cultural competence and medical education: many names, many perspectives, one goal. Acad Med. 2006; 81(6):499-501.
30. Skelton JR, Kai J, Loudon RF. Cross‐cultural communication in medicine: questions for educators. Medical education. 2001 Mar;35(3):257-61.
31. Dwamena F, Holmes-Rovner M, Gaulden CM, Jorgenson S, Sadigh G, Sikorskii A, Lewin S, Smith RC, Coffey J, Olomu A. Interventions for providers to promote a patient-centred approach in clinical consultations. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012;12:CD003267.
32. Maatouk-Bürmann B, Ringel N, Spang J, Weiss C, Möltner A, Riemann U, Langewitz W, Schultz JH, Jünger J. Improving patient-centered communication: Results of a randomized controlled trial. Patient Educ Couns. 2016a; 99(1):117-124.
33. Dowell A, Crampton P, Parkin C. The first sunrise: an experience of cultural immersion and community health needs assessment by undergraduate medical students in New Zealand. Med Educ. 2001b; 35(3):242-249.
34. Harmsen H, Bernsen R, Meeuwesen L, Thomas S, Dorrenboom G, Pinto D, Bruijnzeels M. The effect of educational intervention on intercultural communication: results of a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract. 2005; 55(514):343-350.
35. Stewart M. Reflections on the doctor-patient relationship: from evidence and experience. Br J Gen Pract. 2005; 55(519):793-801.
36. Kirkpatrick DL, Kirkpatrick JL.. Evaluating Training Programs: The Four Levels. 3 ed. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Publishers. 1994
37. Steinert Y, Mann K, Centeno A, Dolmans D, Spencer J, Gelula M, Prideaux D. A systematic review of faculty development initiatives designed to improve teaching effectiveness in medical education: BEME Guide No. 8. Med Teach. 2006; 28(6):497-526
38. Colthart I, Bagnall G, Evans A, Allbutt H, Haig A, Illing J, McKinstry B. The effectiveness of self-assessment on the identification of learner needs, learner activity, and impact on clinical practice: BEME Guide no. 10. Med Teach. 2008a; 30(2):124-145.
39. Aronson K, Venable R, Sieveking N, Miller B. Teaching intercultural awareness to first-year medical students via experiential exercises. Intercultural Education. 2005; 16(1):15-24.
40. Carter MM, Lewis EL, Sbrocco T, Tanenbaum R, Oswald JC, Sykora W, Williams P, Hill LD. Cultural competency training for third-year clerkship students: effects of an interactive workshop on student attitudes. J Natl Med Assoc. 2006; 98(11):1772-1778.
41. Fung CC, Lagha RR, Henderson P, Gomez AG. 2010. Working with interpreters: how student behavior affects quality of patient interaction when using interpreters. Med Educ Online. 2010; Jan 1;15(1):5151.
42. Gilligan C, James EL, Snow P, Outram S, Ward BM, Powell M, Lonsdale C, Cushing AM, Silverman J, Regan T et al. Interventions for improving medical students' interpersonal communication in medical consultations. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2016.
43. Hudelson P, Perron NJ, Perneger T. Self-assessment of intercultural communication skills: a survey of physicians and medical students in Geneva, Switzerland. BMC Medical Education. 2011 Dec;11:1-9.
44. Hudson GL, Maar M. Faculty analysis of distributed medical education in Northern Canadian Aboriginal communities. Rural Remote Health. 2014; 14(4):2664.
45. Kumagai AK, Kakwan M, Sediqe S, Dimagno MM. Actors' personal stories in case-based multicultural medical education. Med Educ. 2010; 44(5):506-507.
46. Kutob RM, Bormanis J, Crago M, Gordon P, Shisslak CM.Using standardized patients to teach cross-cultural communication skills. Med Teach. 2012; 34(7):594.
47. Lee A, Mader E, Morley C. Teaching Cross-Cultural Communication Skills Online: A Multi-Method Evaluation. Family Medicine. 2015; 47(4):302-308.
48. Lie D, Shapiro J, Cohn F, Najm W. Reflective practice enriches clerkship students' cross-cultural experiences. J Gen Intern Med. 2010; 25 Suppl 2:S119-125.
49. McEvoy M, Santos MT, Marzan M, Green EH, Milan FB.. Teaching medical students how to use interpreters: a three year experience. Med Educ Online. 2009;14:12.
50. Niu NN, Syed ZA, Krupat E, Crutcher BN, Pelletier SR, Shields HM.. The impact of cross-cultural interactions on medical students' preparedness to care for diverse patients. Acad Med. 2012; 87(11):1530-1534.
51. Nora LM, Daugherty SR, Mattis-Peterson A, Stevenson L, Goodman LJ. Improving cross-cultural skills of medical students through medical school-community partnerships. West J Med. 1994; 161(2):144-147.
52. Roh H, Nirta L. Medical students interact with multicultural patients to learn cultural diversity. Korean J Med Educ. 2018; 30(2):161-166.
53. Smith JD, Wolfe C, Springer S, Martin M, Togno J, Bramstedt KA, Sargeant S, Murphy B. Using cultural immersion as the platform for teaching Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health in an undergraduate medical curriculum. Rural Remote Health. 2015; 15(3):3144.
54. Sopoaga F, Zaharic T, Kokaua J, Covello S. Training a medical workforce to meet the needs of diverse minority communities. BMC Med Educ. 2017; 17(1):19.
55. Mak DB, Watson R, Hadden J. 2011. Preparing medical students to undertake a cultural immersion experience: Introducing frameworks for preparatory and post-immersion activities. International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning. 5(1).
56. Rosen J, Spatz ES, Gaaserud AM, Abramovitch H, Weinreb B, Wenger NS, Margolis CZ. A new approach to developing cross-cultural communication skills. Med Teach. 2004; 26(2):126-132.
57. Kaul P, Guiton G. Responding to the challenges of teaching cultural competency. Med Educ. 2010; 44(5):506.
58. Hawthorne K, Prout H, Kinnersley P, Houston H. Cultural Competency Interventions During Medical School: a Scoping Review and Narrative Synthesis. Patient education and counselling. 2009; 74(1):5-11.
59. Deliz JR, Fears FF, Jones KE, Tobat J, Char D, Ross WR. Cultural competency interventions during medical school: a scoping review and narrative synthesis. Journal of general internal medicine. 2020 Feb;35:568-77.
60. Woolsey Des Jarlais C. Cultural Characteristics of Western Educational Structures and Their Effects on Local Ways of Knowing. Missoula, Montana: University of Montana. 2009.
61. Caputo J, Crandall H. The intercultural communication cultural immersion experience: Preparing leaders for a global future. Journal of Leadership Studies. 2012; 6(1), 58-63.
62. Beach MC, Price EG, Gary TL, Robinson KA, Gozu A, Palacio A, Smarth C, Jenckes MW, Feuerstein C, Bass EB et al.. Cultural competence: a systematic review of health care provider educational interventions. Med Care. 2005; 43(4):356-373.
63. Butler M, McCreedy E, Schwer N, Burgess D, Call K, Przedworski J, Rosser S, Larson S, Allen M, Fu S. Improving Cultural Competence to Reduce Health Disparities. 2016
64. Litvinova T, Andriutsa N, Movchun V. Developing students’ intercultural communicative competence through online learning. International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning. 2021; Apr 23;16(8):162-72.
65. Saha S, Beach MC, Cooper LA. Patient centeredness, cultural competence and healthcare quality. J Natl Med Assoc. 2008; 100(11):1275-1285.
66. Potocky-Tripodi M. Best Practices for Social Work with Refugees and Immigrants. Columbia University Press. 2002.
67. Goris J, Komaric N, Guandalini A, Francis D, Hawes E. Effectiveness of multicultural health workers in chronic disease prevention and self-management in culturally and linguistically diverse populations: A systematic literature review. Australian Journal of Primary Health. 2013;19(1):14-37.
68. Walsh JM, Salazar R, Nguyen TT, Kaplan C, Nguyen LK, Hwang J, McPhee SJ, Pasick RJ.. Healthy colon, healthy life: a novel colorectal cancer screening intervention. Am J Prev Med. 2010; 39(1):1-14.
69. Sixta CS, Ostwald S. Texas-Mexico border intervention by promoters for patients with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Educ. 2008; 34(2):299-309.
70. Babamoto KS, Sey KA, Camilleri AJ, Karlan VJ, Catalasan J, Morisky DE. Improving Diabetes Care and Health Measures Among Hispanics Using Community Health Workers: Results From a Randomized Controlled Trial. Health Education & Behavior. 2006; 36(1):113-126.
71. Mock J, McPhee SJ, Nguyen T, Wong C, Doan H, Lai KQ, Nguyen KH, Nguyen TT, Bui-Tong N. Effective Lay Health Worker Outreach and Media-Based Education for Promoting Cervical Cancer Screening Among Vietnamese American Women. American Journal of Public Health. 2007; 97(9):1693-1700.
72. Staten LK, Gregory-Mercado KY, Ranger-Moore J, Will JC, Giuliano AR, Ford ES, Marshall J. Provider Counselling, Health Education, and Community Health Workers: The Arizona WISEWOMAN Project. Journal of Women's Health. 2004; 13(5):547-556.
73. Tanaka K, Son D. Experiential learning for junior residents as a part of community-based medical education in Japan. Education for Primary Care. 2019; 30(5):282-288.
74. Thackrah RD, Thompson SC, Durey A. “Listening to the silence quietly”: investigating the value of cultural immersion and remote experiential learning in preparing midwifery students for clinical practice. BMC Research Notes. 2014;7(1):685.
75. Brock MJ, Fowler LB, Freeman JG, Richardson DC, Barnes LJ. Cultural Immersion in the Education of Healthcare Professionals: A Systematic Review. J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2019; 16:4.
76. Bainbridge R, McCalman J, Clifford A, Tsey K.. Cultural competency in the delivery ofhealth services for Indigenous people. Issues paper no. 13. 2015; Produced for the Closing the Gap Clearinghouse. In: Australian, Welfare IoHa, editors. Canberra.
77. Clifford A, Calman J, Jongen C, Bainbridge R. Cultural competency training and education in the university-based professional training of health professionals: characteristics, quality and outcomes of evaluations. Diversity and Equality in Health and Care .2017; 14 (3)
78. Tremethick MJ, Smit EM. Preparing culturally competent health educators: The development and evaluation of a cultural immersion service-learning program. International Electronic Journal of Health Education. 2009;12:185-93.
79. Conroy SF, Taggart HM. The Impact of a Cultural Immersion Study Abroad Experience in Traditional Chinese Medicine. J Holist Nurs. 2016; 34(3):229-235.
80. Williamson HJ, Young BR, Murray N, Burton DL, Levin BL, Massey OT, Baldwin JA. Community-University Partnerships for Research and Practice: Application of an Interactive and Contextual Model of Collaboration. J High Educ Outreach Engagement. 2016; 20(2):55-84.
81. Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, COPMeD. Reflective practice toolkit. [accessed 18 May 2020] http://www.aomrc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Reflective_Practice_Toolkit_AoMRC_CoPMED_0818.pdf ;2018.
82. Plant J, Li ST, Blankenburg R, Bogetz AL, Long M, Butani L. Reflective Practice in the Clinical Setting: A Multi-Institutional Qualitative Study of Pediatric Faculty and Residents. Acad Med. 2017.; 92(11S) Association of American Medical Colleges Learn Serve Lead: Proceedings of the 56th Annual Research in Medical Education Sessions):S75-S83.
83. Barradell S, Ennals P, Burnett M, Karasmanis S, Connors A. Reflective practice in health. https://latrobe.libguides.com/reflectivepractice. 2020.
84. Bernard A, Gorgas D, Greenberger S, Jacques A, Khandelwal S. The Use of Reflection in Emergency Medicine Education. Academic Emergency Medicine. 2012; 19(8):978-982
85. Issenberg SB, McGaghie WC, Gordon DL, Symes S, Petrusa ER, Hart IR, Harden RM. Effectiveness of a cardiology review course for internal medicine residents using simulation technology and deliberate practice. Teach Learn Med. 2002; 14(4):223-228.
86. Weller JM, Nestel D, Marshall SD, Brooks PM, Conn JJ. Simulation in clinical teaching and learning. Med J Aust. 2012;196(9):594.
87. Petticrew M, Egan M, Thomson H, Hamilton V, Kunkler R, Roberts H. Publication bias in qualitative research: what becomes of qualitative research presented at conferences? J Epidemiol Community Health. 2008; 62(6):552-554.