Does silence imply consent? Organ Donation and the Presumption of Informed Consent
Main Article Content
Abstract
In response to the global shortage of organ donation, each country has been applying different public policies to reduce the donor deficit. One of them has been to propose regulatory modifications to the presumed consent system, in order to establish a system in which a favorable will is presumed for post-mortem organ donation, unless the person has declared otherwise while alive.
Recently, the Peruvian law has established the presumed consent system for the donation of organs; it means that, in the absence of express will, the donor's willingness to donate his or her organs at the time of death is now presumed. This regulatory modification follows a tendency established in other countries; however, others remain and respect the free and inform consent regards the willing of donating organs.
This article presents a critical vision of this legal presumption. Under analyzing others health legal systems, we deveal the risks of violation of people's rights when applying a regulation in this sense, which establishes a kind of compelled solidarity, highlighting policies that promote organ donation without compromising fundamental rights.
Article Details
The Medical Research Archives grants authors the right to publish and reproduce the unrevised contribution in whole or in part at any time and in any form for any scholarly non-commercial purpose with the condition that all publications of the contribution include a full citation to the journal as published by the Medical Research Archives.
References
2. Espinoza, Juan. Right of the People. Volume I. 6ª. Edition. Lima: Grijley Legal Editor, 2012: 327.
3. Fernández Sessarego, Carlos. Right of the People. Explanation of reasons and comments on the First Book of the Peruvian Civil Code. 10th. Edition. Lima: Grijley, 2007:59.
4. US Government Health Resources and Services Administration Organ Donation Statistics. HRSA organ donation.gov. Published and Updated in March 2024. Accessed on July 22, 2024. https://donaciondeorganos.gov/conocer/2n8u/estadisticas-sobre-la-donacion-de-organos.
5. “The donation of human organs is inserted within the beliefs and imaginaries that every society shares, which have been built as a culture, as a social fabric, strongly rooted as it wants (sic) that have to do with transcendental human aspects such as death, life, the body, the afterlife” (Carreño, 2016: 85).
6. “Organ donation is not opposed even by faith in the resurrection, which according to Christian doctrine does not mean the material continuation of our earthly body, but rather the profound transformation of the entire man in a new reality that surpasses our capacity to understanding” (Aramini, 2007: 287).
7. International Registry in Organ Donation and Transplantation (IRODaT). International Registry in Organ Donation and Transplantation, Preliminary numbers 2022. Published March 2023. Accessed July 22, 2024. https://www.irodat.org/img/database/pdf/IRODAT%20March%202023%20Preliminary%20report.pdf
8. Agencies, Spain breaks the record for transplants with 5,861 in 2023 and has been the world leader for 32 years in a row. El País Newspaper. Published on January 17, 2024. Accessed on August 4, 2024. https://elpais.com/sociedad/2024-01-17/espana-bate-el-record-de-trasplantes-con-5861-en-2023-y-encadena-32-anos-seguidos-como-lider-mundial.html
9. Aramini, Michele. Introduction to Bioethics. Bogotá: San Pablo, 2007: 284.
10. Rubio Correa, Marcial. The human being as a natural person. 2a. edition. Lima, Pontifical Catholic University of Peru, 1995: 58.
11. Porter K, Villalobos Pérez J, et al. Introduction to Bioethics. 3rd. Edition. Mexico, Méndez Editores, 2009: 183.
12. Aramini, Michele. Introduction to Bioethics. Bogotá: San Pablo, 2007: 270.
13. Espinoza, Juan. Right of the People. Volume I. 6ª. Edition. Lima: Editora Jurídica Grijley, 2012: 333.
14. Congress of the Argentine Nation. Law No. 27447, Law on Transplantation of Organs, Tissues and Cells. Published in the Official Gazette of the Republic of Argentina on July 26, 2018. Accessed on July 23, 2024.
https://www.boletinoficial.gob.ar/detalleAviso/primera/188857/20180726?busqueda=1
15. Undersecretary of Public Health - Ministry of Health. Law No. 20,673, modifies Law No. 19,451 Regarding the Determination of Who Can Be Considered Organ Donors. Published in the Official Gazette of Chile on June 7, 2013. Accessed on August 4, 2024. https://www.diariooficial.interior.gob.cl/media/2013/06/07/do-20130607.pdf
16. Congress of Colombia. Law No. No. 1805, by which law 73 of 1988 and law 919 of 2004 are modified on the donation of anatomical components and other provisions are issued. Published in the Official Gazette of Colombia on August 24, 2016. Accessed on August 4, 2024. https://svrpubindc.imprenta.gov.co/diario/view/diarioficial/consultarDiarios.xhtml
17. Carreño Dueñas, Dalia; Restrepo Restrepo, José and Becerra, Jairo. “Socio-legal aspects of organ donation and transplantation in Colombia.” In: Various authors. Bioethics and teaching. Bogotá: University of Santo Tomás – Ibáñez Publishing Group, 2016: 81.
18. Chamber of Senators, Draft decree that modifies articles 320, 321, 322, 324, 325, 326 and 329 of the General Health Law, approved on April 3, 2018. Available in http://www.senado.gob.mx/sgsp/gaceta/63/3/2018-04-03-1/ assets/documentos/Dict_Salud_Donacion_de_Organos.pdf. Accessed June 2, 2018
19. Ministry of the Presidency. ROYAL DECREE 2070/1999, of December 30, which regulates the activities of obtaining and clinical use of human organs and the territorial coordination in matters of donation and transplantation of organs and tissues. Published in the Official State Gazette of Spain. Published on January 4, 2000. Accessed on July 31, 2024. https://www.boe.es/boe/dias/2000/01/04/pdfs/A00179-00190.pdf
20. For more information, access the information from the National Transplant Organization of Spain:https://www.ont.es/informacion-al-ciudadano-3/donacion-de-organos-3-4/#
21. https://www.organdonor.gov/about-us/legislation-policy/history
22. Perez Look. Conflicts of Conscience Faced with Organ Transplants. Law and Health Magazine, 2015; 25 (2): 81-97. https://www.ajs.es/es/index-revista-derecho-y-salud/volumen-25-numero-2-2015/conflictos-conciencia-los-trasplantes
23. Prange De Oliveira, A and Hallan, M.. German lawmakers reject 'opt-out' organ donor bill. DW. Published January 16, 2020. Accessed July 22, 2022. https://www.dw.com/en/german-parliament-explicit-consent-still-necessary-from-organ-donors/a-52022245
24. On the moral admissibility of the voluntary supply of organs, whether free or not, see Garzón Valdés, Ernesto. “Some ethical considerations about organ transplantation.” In: Vásquez, Rodolfo (compiler). Bioethics and law. Fundamentals and current problems. Mexico: Economic Culture Fund, 1999.
25. Espinoza, Juan. Right of the People. Volume I. 6ª. Edition. Lima: Editora Jurídica Grijley, 2012: 328.
26. Abellán, José Carlos and Lopez Barahona, Mónica. The codes of life. Madrid: Homolegens; 2009.
27. Thaler, Richard. Everything I have learned with economic psychology. The encounter between economics and economic psychology. The meeting between economics and psychology and its implications for individuals. Barcelona: Deusto, 2016:197.
28. Sunstein, Cass and Thaler, Richard. A little push (Nudge). 2a. reprint. Madrid: Penguim Random House Editorial Group. 2018: 207.
29. World Medical Association (WMA). WMA Declaration on Organ and Tissue Donation. Published on July 20, 2022. Accessed August 16, 2024. https://www.wma.net/es/policies-post/declaracion-de-la-amm-sobre-la-donacion-de-organos-y-tejidos/
30. Moreu Carbonell, Elisa. Nudges and public law. Opportunity and regulation. In: Ponce Solé, Julio (Coordinator). Nudges, good government and good administration. Contributions from behavioral sciences, nudging and the public and private sector. Madrid: Marcial Pons, Legal and Social Editions, 2022: 98
31. Cárdenas Krenz, R. “Individual freedom vs. the common good? Lessons from the pandemic and nudges as a vaccination strategy”. 1st Edition, Galicia: Editorial Colex, S.L. 2024: 146-147.
32. Sunstein, Cass and Thaler, Richard. A little push (Nudge). 2a. reprint. Madrid: Penguim Random House Editorial Group. 2018: 203 et seq.
33. Martínez Palomo, Adolfo (compiler). Bioethics: in search of consensus on consent. Mexico: El Colegio Nacional, 2009:15.